In 2009 the Hallmark Channel launched "Countdown to Christmas," which included four original movies made on a modest budget that follow a predictable formula. It was an immediate ratings hit, catapulting Hallmark to the top of the cable charts. Competitors start to take notice, most notably Lifetime, which caters to the same demographic. Three years later, Lifetime launches their own block of Christmas programming called “It’s a Wonderful Lifetime” featuring similar original movies. It kicks off a Christmas movie rivalry that is big business.
Listen to new episodes 1 week early and to all episodes ad free with Wondery+. Join Wondery+ for exclusives, binges, early access, and ad free listening. Available in the Wondery App https://wondery.app.link/businesswars.
Please support us by supporting our sponsors!
KEEPS - Go to keeps.com/BW to get your first month of treatment for free
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
This is an unofficial transcript meant for reference. Accuracy is not guaranteed.
Join one replies to listen a business wars. One week early and ad free
wonder, YAP download the wonder YAP in your apple or Google play Mobile appstore today
It's early evening summer. Twenty seventeen
directions, manager, Jamie Lake, slugs, back lukewarm coffee.
Pulls onto exit to sixteen of the Trans Canada Highway is assessed,
and those in the passenger seat
nudges his assistant shoulder wake up
we're almost there
assistant stretches and takes in the surroundings. What do you think
Times Charm Lake,
non committal grunt. They spent the law
twelve hours criss crossing the greater Vancouver area, scouting Luke,
stations for the upcoming movie, a rocky mountain Christmas for the Hallmark Channel,
it's about a woman who escaped to her uncle s ranch after a break up
it's a Hollywood actor preparing for a row. The town has to be perfect, quaint and welcoming, like the
audiences, stepping into a snow globe, but so far nothing has been quite right:
lake turns right. Then, right again
and suddenly
their driving down the picturesque main street of Fort Langley British Columbia, club
store fronts, painted bright, red, yellow and green line, the streets lashly
trees, dot, the sidewalks signs
advertise bookstores, clothing, boutiques and cozy coffee shops, lakes
distant grabs. His camera bounds out of the car lake adjusted
baseball cat low on his head and ambles after it.
system grins as he takes a photo of an ice cream parlor. This is
What I'm talking about this is a hallmark card, come to life lake strokes, who so
and pepper goatee
in narrows his eyes is perfect
like it was perfect in the six other hallmark movies. I can think of just off the top of my head. We shot here in the past five years. We can't keep
went back to the same old places, they'll lose that magical feeling. Lakes.
Ways: trails officer spots of man
cross. The street snapping photos his assent
and followed. His gaze is at John again ESA
Third time we ve seen him today. You must
scouting for Lifetime
nosing. Yet on our locations come on.
The next item is
we won laughed in his pretty far from Vancouver Lake shrugs.
You don't have a choice,
system nods and the two hall themselves back into the car they
to the next town in search of the perfect street, to create Christmas,
movie magic. The lifetime
scouts right behind you
paid up to two days early with direct deposit is another reason: banking with capital. One is one of the easy
decisions in the history of decisions, even easier
Then deciding to listen to another episode of your favorite pot, guessed at with
fees or minimums on checking and savings accounts come on. Is it even a decision
That's banking, re imagined! What's in your wallet term supply see cap.
One dot com, slash bag
capital, one in a member. After I see.
Ready for a new rights, but not sure where to start meet the tool that makes car shopping and financing easier
with capital one auto navigator, you can find a car and get pre qualified instantly. Yogurt.
you're, real rate and monthly payment, without even impacting your credit score in fact is
simple? You might feel like you're taking the easy way out. That's because you are capital, one. What's in your wallet terms and conditions apply
find out more capital, one dot com, slash auto navigator,.
From one I'm David Brown, and this is business wars,
Christmas is this season: the deck the halls build: snowman, sip, hot chocolate in exchange, present
floodlit, wherever the
ass ten years, a new tradition
has emerged
watching low budget holiday movies made for television plots
hello, familiar lines theirs.
royalty Christmas, fast
those that save the town baking
contest that advance the protagonists career
city, women falling in love with small town, men precocious
children setting up their single parents and so forth, whatever shape the plot
eggs, the hero or heroin fines
and weekends, their Christmas spirit and
always
Paul ways snows on Christmas, other
These movies are derided, is cheesy and silly. They are big business
Bringing in millions in advertising revenue then keep
their channels afloat.
in two thousand and nine the Hallmark Channel launches cap down to Christmas starting
day after Thanksgiving they air
four hundred fifty hours of holiday programming and for me
for original movies by Christmas, its array,
his usual
rank somewhere between tenth and twentieth, most watched, cable channels in December. They
come the number one table channel in the country,
Completing channel lifetime takes no and in twenty twelve they
their own block of Christmas programming, with original movies at the center
barks rivalry that has lasted almost a decade and shows no signs of abating too
companies are locked into an arms race producing more and more Christmas Moody's each year play by women
each other for locations, actors, crew and, of course, viewers.
And when streaming behemoth. Netflix moves in by producing its own Christmas movies. Weather
competition only becomes more intense in our new
I part, series we dive into the carpet.
action between hallmark lifetime and Netflix as they battle it.
To be America's primary destination for Christmas movies,
while the films may be full of good will and cheer
the rivalry
cold and dark is a lump of coal. This is episode, one
a very merry bribery
its September. Twenty ten in LOS Angeles Bill Abbot this
He'll of Crown media, which owns the Hallmark Channel and Michel victory. The head of hallmark programming sitting
screening room at the company's headquarters,
outside its our record breaking one hundred thirteen degrees, but on the screen, the actors done
markers and drink hot chocolate at Christmas. Parade really want me to blog about crazy old man who thinks abbot,
Their career watching footage from a movie currently shooting in Canada, and they are not happy
it scheduled premier in just a few months as part of their second ever count down to Christmas Block of programming and its
not what they envisioned decoration
her head and frustration. Her long white
Herr sachet across her back
victories in her late forties. She got
starting music working with bands like Nirvana and whole, but
television was always her passion. What is this? I should like to
Christmas lights behind them. It should be times
we're back their Christmas lights everywhere, Abbot
his hand over his balding head, sharing, VIC
Greece prostration
forty eight years old abbots been with crown media since, before the hallmark general even existed, he started
advertising sales and only became ceo last year. One of his first
major decisions. Was Tibet big on Christmas movies, but now he's having his doubts.
I thought we were clear and appropriate meetings. Every
these two explode with Christmas. This is hinting at Christmas
audience sees a whole more movie is a magical world. That sense of wonder: that's how we compete against the classics. Abbot
slumps in his seat,
their channels, notably ABC family, which is owned by Disney and
cast networks, have the resources to air classic Christmas films they show
movies, like it's a wonderful life, a Christmas story in Polar Express during December. In contrast
Crown Media's independently owned. They have to make their own films small budgets
one third of our total lad revenue. Last year in November and December, we can't
where'd. You get this wrong. You think weeks
production, do much last year,
more channel premier for region
Christmas movies.
This year there slated to premier tan bakery shakes
head adamantly. We crunch them.
Worse, we sign
much our ratings increase last year
Viewers are hungry for Christmas programming. We just have to get our film
yours on board there, not just making films
brand ambassadors and our brand is Christmas magic once we get them
understand them. Will beholden Abbot sits up, Strader and reaches for a cell phone? Your right is
too late to correct as their only on day, three filming. We can impress on them the importance of having Christmas in every inch of the frame bakery nods. Don't worry, we'll
dominate Christmas, we're the only
people doing what we do at the scale. We do it. That's a real edge, high Jason each bill. Listen
I need to talk to production as soon as possible, but across the country,
another channel has taken notice of hallmarks success,
they want in on the Christmas cheer
it's twenty. Eleven fancy, Dubuque paces
in front of a conference room a lifetime entertainments headquarters in New York City Dubuque edge.
sir glasses. In her,
early forties Dubuque took over his head of lifetime. Last year after running
history channel. She turned that
it works rating woes around. By cutting back on some of the serious documentaries the channel was famous for
Producing a slate of reality shows including ponds
cars and ice road truckers shows
a cheap to produce and prove popular
winning combination now she's tasked with
by giving the lifetime channel in
a few minutes, a stream
executives will enter the conference room and she's going to tell
about her new vision that includes
and her team everything there doing. That's not working. She
how's. This won't be a fun conversation that it has to be done. The door opens and
twenty executives, violin taking seats
Round the table Dubuque smiles,
as soon as everyone seated Dubuque closes the door. She looks at it
grim faces of the executive staring at her. Ok, we might as well dive in
it's no secret. I was brought into give this channel and make over my predecessor,
it took some gambles that didn't know
pay off
obviously the biggest with securing the rights to project runway from Bravo, three
Unfortunately, didn't follow,
May we have some incredible scripted series. I love army wives and dropped the diva, but we have to face the facts.
That their audiences are shrinking and
the executive holds a legal pad in front of his mouth,
grasses to his seat neighbour, how much you
bet, she's gonna suggests we need to expand our reality slate. So much to you
to produce. You know his seat, nay.
Chuckles quietly! No way, I'm not taking that bad as what every higher up says these days, Dubuque takes, it
sip of water, then
launches into the next part of her presentation,
Now I know a lot of you are worried that I'm going to turn lifetime into a reality, television factory and that's
concern given my track record at the history channel and its true theirs.
To expand our reality offerings but
I also want to lean into what we're doing well right now,
killing it in the original movie game.
there's a big area where we could expand our offerings Christmas
We should be doing our own block of Christmas,
programming. The way homework is the older
accurate than his neighbor exchange are confused. Look the older
negative leaned forward. This
ass, a nine. I have to say something.
Older executive, raises his hand,
I dont mean any disrespect here but
our original movies, tend to have
salacious spin, I mean
The titles we produce since I've been here include my steps on my lover and see
quit sins of the father. Co egg call girl, you know I I know
and Christmas movies here and there, but does it make
and to make them a big part of our brand Dubuque shakes her head. She antics.
baited. This response
lifetime made its first Christmas movie in nineteen. Ninety nine, that's before them.
Mark Channel even existed, but we ve seated the market. Here's around.
We average higher ratings than homework. All your long, then the holiday season comes along and they completely outperform us. They go.
after the same demographic. We do women. Twenty five to fifty four occur.
Into the numbers. They want Christmas movies,
I want our version of countdown to Christmas. Let's get crack economic, she
visas are eyebrow at the elder executive as if asking him guided the eggs.
active grudgingly nods,
the executive stream out Dubuque hopes, hurt
confidence in this strategy pays off.
The holiday season is a wonderful lifetime. Its October eleven twenty twelve LOS Angeles homework
negative bill Abbot and Michel victory or watching a pre
you for lifetimes newly announced block of Christmas programming, decoration
ex her head. Well, they do
say: imitation is the greatest form of flattery, at least
preparing fourteen new movies. They ve only got ten trickery wings
Amateurs they both chuckle, then
Victory drops her smile,
the serious, am not worried. Surely
time is a cable channels older than the Hallmark channel, but home
itself is a hundred and ten year old company and one of them
well defined brands in the world,
Our movies are a perfect representation of that brand. Do they really think people
going to tune into the same channel that airs things called my boyfriend. This
serial killer for the holidays, ebbed tugs. At his tie
raised on long island. He still is in use to how hot the folly is in LOS Angeles stew.
It wouldn't hurt up our game a little bit. I mean
we're thinking about next year list just make sure we're not getting complacent. We don't want to take anything for granted victory,
Jeanne agreement. It might makes
and to increase our star power, find an actor
who can really serve as the face of the company that consensus apart.
her lifetime, definitely plus, of course, more movies.
lifetimes, jumping in with ten who knows how many they'll add. Next year agreed,
we have some work to do but
finding a star for their movies won't be as easy as they think and soon another bigger company.
will be unwrapping their own Christmas movie, treats.
There are a lot of things about getting some years under your belt that are pretty cool. For one thing, you have more experience,
Therefore, a little more confidence prefer allotted
eyes. There's something else. It happens as you age, two out of three of men will experience some form of hair lost by the time. Their thirty five, I know that's,
true for a lot of my friends and it can be pretty tough to deal with, but here's the thing prevention is key and there
or to FDA, approved medications that can prevent hair laws and our sponsor keeps offers both keeps is
simple stress free way to keep your hair when you use keeps you'll get convenient virtual
doktor consultations and medications delivered straight.
Your door indiscreet packaging every three months, its low cost treatments star,
just ten dollars a month, and they offer generic versions of their medications to keep
has more five star reviews than any of its competitors because they deliver proven results, so try them out. Today. Treatments can take forty
months to see results. So the earlier you get started the better. If you're ready to take action and prevent hairless go to k e e p s, dot com slash be w to get your first month of treatment for free, that's k, e p s, not calm, Slash be w to get your first month free one more time. That's keeps k, E p s, dot, com, Slash be W. We get support
from the new podcast cover story. Ketamine therapy guided mushroom trips, people are calling it the psychedelic renaissance. But what are we going?
Looking in a rush to feel better power trip is the first season of cover story
investigative series from New York magazine uncovering the secrets behind this new revolution that no one wants to talk about its story: revolving around charismatic shamans, secret, colts and deep pocketed investors.
willing to ignore at all. But ultimately it's a tale about mind. Body and control. Follow cover story on Spotify.
Apple or wherever you listen
its spring, twenty thirteen, in LOS Angeles Hallmarks
gives Bill Abbot and Michel victory, are meeting
The casting director hallmark estate
Head of lifetime in the ratings, but
last year, lifetime had its best year yet and hallmark here.
It a snag with its quest to find a channel defining star the casting doubt
takes a deep breath. It's time to,
Liver, the bad news, unfortunately,
everyone on our initial list has turned us down mode
agents are saying that pay is just too low. Average
in his chair annoyed. Did you
explained that every year we have over a thousand hours of holiday programming to fill
we re air movies all the time they make up the difference in residuals the castle.
director nods. I did, but I think there is a bigger problem they looked down on us
It still seen as a blemish on people's resonates to being a hallmark movie. You know
his coastal elite ISM our holiday
programming brought in over fifty six million viewers last year, but the end
three things we're a Joker Bakery whose
and staring at the window turns. I think we just
to embrace who we are
Many channels are going dark and edgy they
it shows about science. Teachers turned meth dealers and murderous congressmen
never gonna, be us we're, never gonna, be hip worthy channel.
people who want to remember simpler times.
get away from politics and darkness the cast.
Director nods understand
What victories getting at our casting
tap into those feelings actors who bring up the nostalgia in
It helps if they haven't worked much recently. People
just remember them from their early roles.
She crosses to a whiteboard in begins. Writing if our
poor demographic. Is women aged twenty five to fifty four abbot crosses next to her
and we you to the older side of that the casting director nods.
Then we want to target actors who were on hit shows in the Eightys and Ninetys ice.
Civically say shows because those are the act.
she came into living rooms week after week they were their friends, neighbours Russia's
off the top of my head. I'm thinking the wonder years,
oh, how safe by the Bell boy meets world. The cash
director nods and rights them down. I definitely think
Our stars on these shows that will be thrilled to appear in hallmark movies even more than one year. We need
who embody are wholesome tradition minded brand. No one edge
you're already o indefinitely
What a criminal record homeward casts lorry Laughlin,
who started his aunt Becky on full house in two of its series. She asked
agrees to be in a Christmas moving making her
ACE of Hallmark going in
twenty thirteen holiday season hallmark fields
about their prospects against lifetime, but it
pocketed rival is about to spite
the ignored
its December twentieth, twenty fourteen.
Karen jailer sits in a small New York City apartment furiously typing in her beat up laptop
Seven years ago, at age, forty scheiler gave up a successful broadcast journalism career
to New York to become a screenwriter. It hasn't
then the fairy tale journey. She imagined the economy,
ash less than a year after her move and she's here.
The cash out her for a one k to support herself, but she hasn't
But up her dreams and over
holidays she's deter
and to write this next script. She really believe
it could sell their produce.
She recently met thinks so too.
Reaches the end of the page and reads back what she wrote: Prince richer,
amber and princess Emily, throw snowballs at each other, they laugh ass.
Snowball hits Mark Amber slips Prince Richard
to landing on top of her. They look
to each other's eyes time stops there
Heads draw near to each other,
suddenly a snowball pelts Prince Richard and the shoulder princess, Emily
No socializing with the enemy
Schiller's smiles to herself almost kiss shack jailer,
loves, hallmark movies and she has studied there formula extensively.
She knows they have nine acts in an almost kiss, always
occurs in act: seven
sailors phone rings, it's one of her, for
it's from back home in Seattle, hey
I forgot to call you yesterday for your birthday, I'm the worse but actually you're the worse for not coming home for Christmas, your Christmas, Karen! No, unless Christmas more than you do, I can't believe
Gonna, be all by yourself. I know, but I really want to finish the script.
Excited about it. It's
a journalist who travels to Europe to look into rumours that a princess going to advocate the throne. She goes under
however, as a tutor for his younger sister and finds out, there's more to the prince than meets the eye and they fall in love. Of course, I love it. Good luck at all that the creative flow. Shame.
get back to work. Turning up the hallmark movie, she's been playing in the background she wants to capture the tone perfectly
The downside of writing this type of movie is that there are no
places she can sell it if she can't secure
green light from hallmark or lifetime
Why not get another chance? It's twenty! Sixteen, too
years later jailers sitting in the basement of Fox NEWS, where she works as a correspondent. She doesn't like it, but she needs the paycheck
She checks. The collar idea is to produce.
she's been working with on her Christmas grip. How I got good news, your script so
Sheeler let out a silent, scream and pumps. Her fists and excitement
leave my movies going to be on hallmark
hallmark, didn't buy it lifetime. No, it's netflix.
Shaler surprised but not disappointed
The term movies getting made the more people making these movies that better for her career. She
continues to dance in her cubicle. The executives at hallmark lifetime quite is pleased
carved out niches in the industry by making cheap content in bulk. But Netflix is
the death STAR attack come
with a seemingly unlimited budget
both companies will have to up their games to compete with each other and Netflix. But
their attempts to outdo each other sacho
the market
our next episode. We go back in time to the origins of hallmarks foray into television and see how a young, flailing, cable channels saved itself
embracing the Christmas Spirit.
from wondering this is episode one of Christmas movie wars for business wars, if you like,
Oh, please give us a five star rating in a review and be sure to tell your friends
follow business wars on Apple podcast, Spotify, Spotify, Amazon, music, wonder Riyadh wherever you're listening right now, you can listen ad free by joining wondering plus
we'll, find him links and offers from our sponsors and the episode notes. Supporting them helps us keep offering our shows for free and other way you can
all this shows by filling out a small survey. It wondering dot com, slash survey and tell us which
the stories you'd like to hear a quick note about
recreations you ve been hearing.
Cases we can't know exactly what was said. Those scenes are dramatization, but their based on historical research,
David Brown. Austin Rackliff wrote this story voice
doing by Michel. Philippine
Karen Low is our senior producer and editor edited and pretty
by Emily Frost. Sound designed by Kyle Random are produced
Dave shelling. Our executive producers are Jenny, Lauer, Beckmann and Martial Louie created
or non Lopez before wondering.
In a world where aliens crash land that world would be called the planet earth envy
he left the human talk he was just getting to the part. I am follow. Flip
policy as they travel all over planet earth, meeting different animal species in trying to learn
with original songs by the pop ups
so superior wrought joined them every week for new adventure. Weapon mosey meet some of the most amazing creatures and learned TAT Live Mosey guide. How to be an earthly is available. Every Thursday on Apple pie casts Amazon, music or listen as free. One week, early tie, subscribing to wondering, plus kids apple pie, casts or wondering plus wondering.
Transcript generated on 2021-12-02.