This is a thousand people reason their butts off, waiting, no worship our rat. What I They use the mean something in this town. They used up all these. They ate it. Your have put Allah You got a problem with what I'm saying: Larry, I'm tired you come out here and talk lab setting? I have setting you princess, you want diction about the weather, you're asking the wrong fill a gift. Winter prediction

It's great! That's gonna, arrest! Welcome your more now there's a lot Willie, there's so much at America, the heartbeat America beaten stronger. You know really when set out some along whenever he saw a weather, bleeding dark and bereft of yet we know that winter is just another step in the cycle of wine and watching these people, the great people of foxes, haughty and basking in the warmth of their hearts and hearts and hearts. I couldn't imagine a better fate than along an illustrious winter well yeah. I know You feel the same power you feel the same. Powerful yet lived in little letters,

It is safe and film worry both like an intense concert for six hours, that smash mouth get nasty their pages compensatory Pennsylvania, its ground, they make a very exciting. I said steady. I never could remember whether it sees its shadow if its Morse bring their last spring and what it is, and I wondered some research this morning to only made it worse. I dont understand did Jeff if its clear out it seems the shadow that goes back into the den for six more. Why would you go back into the Danube? Is a beautiful day, let's get out there and start swing early, it's actually the opposite. Confused than ever, but I enjoy the day was a great movie. Let's take a lesson for a second

so tardy three cobblers now gamblers count at its wow. I am is what I'm done. That's not where we didn't do these things die a couple days ago story: One of these New Jersey

Hulu Meares at our Groundhog desk with enough date for us what happened in IRAN and Libya ass. What I will say, I have a bit of expertise in this sense I did cover was built of laws, YO dropped, the Grand Haagen murdered him years. I went and steady hall at the time, so I can evaluate this. Yes, grandmother. New Jersey died a few days ago. Not this one, not Pugsy Tawny, Phil, but there is either there's a tragic Paul cast over the entire groundhog community. What is normally their biggest day of the year, whether they see their shadow or not entity, is Groundhog Data movie. I put it for me, top ten of all time, and here is we're, seeing, I believe, footage from a few years ago of the mare there's the groundhog. There goes the ground hog and I will just wrap this up, that the lead that I'm most proud of in my entire journalist career came from this story. I said to lead. The lead was the shadow was one

ass things. He saw so did background die. Yes, yeah so let me ask you: did the Plaza plea out? I mean this is before criminal justice reform giving plea our demands they knocked down, demands road and slaughtered really ground dropped by two bloggers, YO dies. Oh my god. I had one of the defining moments of his legacy. Frankly and precise reasons. My head off did not to run for governor that shares. They knew you couldn't get degree ass usual stayed seriously. That's look into these folks and studies in the town of origin pilot. That's what I'd ground now that I've hurry really, nor no doubt makers

goals furry ground down their meagre. Don't you don't do that on that last time? So well, let's, oh my! Let's, let's put back here, oh he's Bloomberg some problem. This is when gloomier bluebird was by a groundhog. You can see it there. He's requires in pain. Again I this when you of your city hall and have to learn things about grand hubs and mayors- and this is another famous mishap where this matter is beaten by the groundwater Staten Island there. He should have taken a message Ok, Lastra, Jerome, gamblers today, rather than a neural. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome the morning Joe and with us today talking about Groundhog Day, we have wow, I think, one of the foremost experts on the east coast on the topic. Professor Princeton University, Eddie,

junior. I also MSNBC contributor and best selling author of the, evidence code Series: Caddy K, nature. I think we ve talked enough about ground hogs. What's in the new all right, let's get to our headlines. This morning yesterday we told you of the new reporting on how personally involved Donald Trump was in trying to use set. The agencies to seize voting machines in case wings. it's in the weeks after losing the twenty twenty election. This morning, the near times reports the January six committee is now investigating trumps role in trying to seize voting machines. That's, according to three but with knowledge of the committee's activities. The time says it's unclear. What that is the law makers are examining, but likely in the mix. Is the draft executive order that circle waited among the former presidents attorneys that would have authorized the Pentagon

to see voting machines in Queen key swing states, but tromp has his own idea for the investigation. He says Congress should investigate like pants. New statement released yesterday, the former president said congressional investigators should look into quote why my pants didn, send back the votes for resource suffocation or approval. The statement appears to be an attempt to clean up or add new wants to his statement from Sunday night that pence quote We have over turned the election Senate minority later Mitch. Mcconnell responded yesterday to trumps comments from his weekend, rally in taxes that he might part January six rioters if he is re elected, take a lesson to that it's all here on January, the six was an effort to prevent the peaceful

transfer of power from one administration to another. One hundred and sixty five have pleaded guilty to criminal behaviour. My view I would not be in favour of shortening any of the sentences or any other people pleaded guilty to crimes, there. We have again Willie. We have Mcconnell making straight out on January the sex. It's one thing again that time and again mixes unambiguous about, and that is that the people than that committing crimes in January. The six should be punished. That January six was an atrocity and one we're Donald Trump is saying about January. Six is not true and again he was to empower the January Sixth commission, which of course

He was against a bipartisan and by camera. Commission, which, I think was a mistake. Mansion thinks it was a mistake. Alot of people do but Certainly I got mine this when he wants wants thank you was the dirty truth, told about Donald Trump, because I think he wants Trump out of the party as much as well a lot of people as much as list Cheney or are are, Others its unclear? It will accomplish that goal, but the truth will be told in its being accumulated and assembled right now by the January six Select Committee, thanks to this wealth of evidence they have about president drop, including him on tape, asking a city Secretary of State in Georgia to find the votes to flip that elected him at Eddie. It is it says so much about where we are that it is considered extraordinary that Mitchell What can I say? No, you shouldn't pardon criminals or in January six seems like an obvious truth, but

There has to be said out loud. I now gives us a sense of the state of things I mean one of the things has been revealed over and over again as the scale of what was possible that we were on the precipice what Donald Trump was trying to do, something we could use the language that he was trying to nuances statement. I mean nuance and Donald Trump, like oil, little water. We know exactly what he was trying to do and that is being coming in ever more clear to us. So it makes sense that Mitch. Mcconnell in Lindsey, Graham, would actually say the obvious. It's just a little too late. It seems from meanwhile wasn't happy with Republican Centre, Lindsey Gram, who criticized tromp before those comments about possible, pardons here's, a reminder of what Senator Graham said on Sunday, followed by trumps new comments in an interview with news MAX

I think, is inappropriate and I dont want to reinforce that. The following the capital was ok. I want to do anything that would make this more likely in the future our wanted to deter people who did what the January the six and those who did it. I hope they go to jail and get the book thrown Adam costs. They deserve it grams wrong. I mean lunges a nice coverage arena Lindsays wrong for these people are being treated horribly. I would absent We, some of them are being treated very unfairly up. I would apps possibly give them pardon some of these people are not guilty. Many of these people are not guilty. What David? I do too and, in many cases, patriots the soldiers that policeman, they ve done to them compared to they ve done to the other side. You know you have. Equal justice, and this is an equal partner. So I would absolutely be prepared at Lindsey Graham, doesn't know what the hell he's talking about. if he says that, because you have to

equal justice. It's very, very unfair. What's happened this group of people talking about about wiles equivalency. Yet there were soldiers and- and cops their soldiers and cops there who had planned. They commit sedition against the United States of America. I'm gonna go to jail for a very long time, because you don't try to overturn the United States government are, the way of peaceful transition. It isn't sing now, which were connell- I must say this again- Mcconnell since January. The six has been very consistent. Very listen What interesting is other Republicans are starting to speak out like midst. Against what happened on January, the sixth Lindsey Gram who's on the Trump train off the Trump train on the Trump train now is off the drug trade et in. Let's take the most extreme example: Josh Holly just Ali a guy, you really

In large part responsible for this insurrection, along with Donald Trump said, If somebody committed a crime on January, the six at the capitol I should face the consequences I just you know, there's an old bill Clinton saying that if a turtle sitting up on a faint transposed, it did get there by accident. I think it's an accident that all these republicans understand that Tis the season to start condemning people that speed Crap on the walls of the United States capital that windows shatter the windows took him. Can flags and best the brains out of out of the copse so hard that they thought they were going to die the jail the cops ads insides adores try, The cause dire agenda harm to them, Jonathan Wellmere There was a silence among women.

Begins and now we're starting. They hear Republic can say these people should face consequences. I suddenly, there are no longer just tourists- sudden in January the six. Why wasn't just another day in the point I'm getting too is I think they're starting in see it in polls that Americans the more they find out about the planning the comments addition against mad, asserting democracy, the anger even the republican base is getting

return of January six to the headlines here after the one you're anniversary and now the committee this. That committee has taken a more public approach to what their work is. S had a bit of an impact here, and certainly the former presidents words more than any other we're we're seeing this as an issue where some Republicans were willing to break with him, and certainly it wouldn't find tool or politics, more loyal without Trump and Josh Holly. Of course, he was the first senator to announced that he would objective two certifying that win for Joe Biden. We all remember the footage of him walking into the cap that day with his fist raised to the crowd, but even he is saying the idea pardons for these rioters areas is a bridge too far that he wouldn't go for that, and we end this several times several times a said. This saying that he wouldn't do that as well. Mcconnell, interesting you're right. Let's put it asked her. So what you said Mccall did still say, though, that truck or their publican nominated twenty four. He would support him. But beyond that he has created a lot of daylight between himself and the four present. He clearly doesn't want trunk to be. The nominee in

on twenty four and thinks the party would be better off in another direction will need to see- and this will only be a question of time, weeks months ahead, whether Republicans are willing to separate themselves for Trump on any other issue or whether it is simply the most extreme aspects of Janeway six. Is this the one thing that they feel like they can't go along, or did I did? It supports continue this way too. They start to break themselves. Further still head on morning, Joe the stand off between Moscow and the West shows no signs of easing. What russian President Vladimir Putin is now saying about. The escalating tensions over Ukraine will toxic caddy about that plus the NFL is facing a new bombshell, lawsuit using the League of Racist hiring practices, we'll talk out the significance of this new legal fight and the private text, messages from Bilbil check at the center, the law. Suit. Also had a stunning new look at the toll, the Corona VI,

this pandemic in United States Cove, it is killing Americans at a far higher rate than people in other. Healthy nations, we're going to break down data here Jim Morning, Joe, will be well sometimes worthy. I there's some parts of that story. I just don't get we'll talk about that. Little bit, we'll be right back, it used to be hard to find the exact out apart, you needed, and that met spent in a lot of time. It's what meets its different game. Now, when you can order exactly what you need from Ebay Motors, they have a hundred and twenty two million parts, so you can always find the right figment, spend less time searching and more time building with the Ebay Motors at or visit Ebay Motors that come, let's ride

I am Tom Yarmouth and for me the news is so much more than a headline you didn't Forbes, it inspires and it still matters to. You have to begin and that's what my new show is gonna do will take you to the front lines of the store ports actually happening with NBC News journalists on the ground from all over the world. We cover what you need to know and bring war newspeak delight in private. In streaming live it's your used, playlist joined for top store, weak seven eastern on NBC News now never stop saying this. The fact that you the habit. In our view, minority cultures is a problem. That's the problem that That's the seed and the foundation of it because to save face is to create this whole utopia that everybody is equal when they fail in everybody's, given equal opportunity. So no sought above Lorries

Foulon loss, who donate shocked when the details come out, don't exist We ve been taught like rats, and we ve been talking about this and we this couch in it as the inner fail. Needless to say, leave office. We need the stores and owners, but enough fail owners order was that determine who would be the aid culture, sport at football teams and they have no incentive to our black coaches. that is former Anna fell. Defensive ended espionage, football commentator now, market spears, insisting league owners are responsible for the alleged discriminatory practices in football. That's in reference to the lawsuit file yesterday by former Miami Dolphins, coach, Brian Flores, alleging racial discrimination against the NFL in three of its teams, the dolphins, the giants and the Broncos. Here

the eight page suit Father Manhattan Federal court yesterday seeks class action status and comes after the forty year old was fired by Miami last month in the suit Floris alleges he was treated with disdain and cast as the angry black man by the dolphins after he refused to accept a one hundred thousand dollars game offer from his team in his first season, two tank, so it could secure a top draft. an explosive allegation an after he would not banned against pressure to recruit a prominent quarterback in violation of the least tampering rules. this led my me to a twenty four twenty five record over three seasons: the team recently finnish, nine and ate, and its second straight winning season, but failed to make the playoffs during his tenure dolphins, released to state in denying any obligation of racial discrimination floor as also alleged the giants interviewed him last month for their head coaching vacancy for no other reason than compliance with the NFL Rooney rule, which require

teams to interview minority candidates. This came to light according to the law suit. In part due to tax from New England Head coach, build Belgic in which he mistakenly congratulated Floris forget the giants, job responded in a statement. Writing in part. The fact of the matter is brine. Flores was in the conversation to be our head coach until the eleventh hour. Ultimately, we hire the individual. We felt was most qualified to be our next head coach. The lawsuit also ledges Flores, was forced to undergo a sham interview with the Broncos and twenty nineteen which the team has dismissed, is blatantly false. In a statement the least said it will defend against these claims, which are without merits so Eddie. Let's get the foot stuff out the way Brian Floris three years ago, in here, the worst team in the NFL, their guard, roster terrible team- could have gone in sixteen eighty one five games last year,

please until winning record this year. They, when aid of nine games on the doorstep of the play off, they don't quite gate in by any measure. He has shown progress in his job in Miami and we should point out there now these one black hair, ocean. The Anna found that's my Tomlin, who was an institution in the legend in Pittsburgh, but that's it that's it. In twenty twenty two one black head coach with so much percent of the league black players flexible be clear he I remember the days when we were excited about duck: Doug Williams, taking the Washington, then the Washington Redskins to the civil. I remember the days when Jimmy the Greek on Monday Football leave that racist come. I remember the days when they are worse top, wouldn't Doug Williams became the butler hit the that the quarterback of the Watson risk, and what does this mean? Is historic? Bacon lead all the underlying assumptions about the mental state of blood

players and black athletes, and it still operative in the league today, and so this to me is a historic moment: it's courageous on the part of coach lorries to step out and call to the for what is has obvious, hardly Indeed, I feel right behind she'll is ugliness and we need and he's making it clear to me for making clear- seems to me. yeah yeah and Jonathan Mayor. I'm so glad that Eddie brought up Doug Williams, because I remember like a lot of people being really excited when Doug Williams finally won the Superbowl. When a black quarterback finally won the Superbowl. He was the euro the first really to be given the chance, and it was, a big thing even in what was that I think January, the eighty nine, maybe in eighty eight but yeah.

eighty eight seas and, yes January, very niner. Thank you now idea here, right, general mediate, but anyway, that seems to be such a big deal within five ten years can really wasn't a big deal suddenly poor realized, dragged away to weaken, recruit black quarterbacks and they can leader teams, and we don't think much, it now, but coaching Wendy? Twenty two: the fact that there is one black coach in the inner fail is so our rageous one head coach and I just really brought up a good point The floor is one eight out of nine games: dolphins, one eight nine games, but the most. part of that is he wanted a out of the last nine games he coached you know about. With a month left the season Scarborough do I bring up

of life that we watch football together, because man that All things are really come on strong and We need to go down and see some dolphin games. This isn't team on fire. He wins mine. He beats the drift in the season finale. Fire him, I'm sorry, Can I say it? No white coach one eight out of nine of his last games and being valid check, finally game of the season code would have been fired in that situation, not one and to underscore just how noteworthy those accounts because work that file gave it a season. At that point, the dolphins, they had won a bunch of aims role, but they had been eliminated, but the patriots needed that game. They still had a chance to win the division and dolphins

anyway, wars is was a star on Bela checks. Staff, as a defensive coordinator was seen, is rising star in the head. Coaching ranks as well, and when this is all seas and started, the dolphins surprisingly fired in now we're learning more about the circumstances there, but there is a belief that he was gonna, be a hot, proper. The Higgins snap right up by some other by some our team. Personally, I was hoping you'd returned. The patriots is defensive coordinator, eventual become Bela checks, apparent ease that good. So it is, it is striking here that he hasn't gotten a job and his allegations are damning and the idea of the inner fell having contrasted the NBA. Another Lee, where majority of players or african American that has quite good much much better representation in terms of black, had coaches, the NFL down to one, and this in part, comes to light because of the aforementioned Bilbil check, sending a text message: series of texts to Florence, congratulating him for getting the giants job it turned out. He got Para

got his name's mix up into stones? Address book meant to send it to the Buffalo bill system coach? Who would eventually get the giants job for us, even had an interview with the giants yet at that post at that time, meaning the job had already been awarded so to someone else and Flora says his interview, a sham the heart of this case. Boy, I tell you what will be the part of this, really that the race parties is. Obviously the centre of this laws, but I will tell you why, cause real problems, for the dolphins is if evidence does come out that their owner was telling the coach throw the games pay you a hundred thousand dollars for every game, the youth row, every game that we lose. That's enough to get an owner stripped of its football team of fats proven you can't

I mean that so much worse than anything, PETE rose every day for the order is paying a head coach throw football games. That can continue the team and they fell. The outlets become the sum headline in the story, because the headline is so important by God. If that's true and I'm sure the NFL right now this morning is looking into the allegation of whether an owner off hundred grams per game to throw games to lose games? Gator hired traffic that would be terrible. I also point out David colleague also black coach was given one season with the Houston Texas. He was fired after this year. They had a rough seas and but he only one year didn't get a chance to turn it around in Houston, let's Brian, Charles Common and Danny Civil US into our conversation. They both are MSNBC Legal, analyse Charles Good morning to you. You ve got a chance to look through this lawsuit. What jumps out at you

when we first of all, I think it is both equal parts. Ironic imposed by the deadline for us has engaged is very explosive lawsuit at the time that he has to kick off like history. Most of all places make no mistake about it. This is a civil rights question. What life or as is saying, is that, because of his race, he was denied upward, eke and equal opportunity to actually compete for this job and is also alleging that other, similarly situated people, meaning other black qualified coaches, have been denied the same opportunities which respect to being able to achieve closer positions and innovation. I think Joe we hit the nail on the head in terms of with actual confer lies beyond the civil rights implications that this has for Flores from competitive, fairly standpoint. The ineffective needs to be extremely concerned about where this rotten king can go alternately view are providing a lives. What product for Europe for the public for your audience for your patrons, and you can ensure that this is truly competitive, ensuring fair, a damn. It is your brain beyond repair, so even with respect to the employment claims which at the boys makes out very very strongly in the initial pleadings there's a significant amount of reputational damage that independence to be peace, be prepared about with respect to this lawsuit, so Danny, all three teams named in this lawsuit deny the allegations the Anna fell says. The claims are without merit. What jumped attitudes you look at this in terms of class action. Who else can be involved here, while one

jumped out at me was one statistic that, if true is very sobering in its that at least two Thirdly, when the Rooney rule was instituted, the role that requires an interview of at least one black candidate for any open had coaching job there were. I three black had coaches at that time now today, There is one so the complain alleges we ve gone backwards and, if that's true, then it seems that we have at least the NFL has gone or in the rue DE ruled, may not have work the way it was intended to work but You, as you ask your question, this is a class action, so there is an addition obstacle. Class actions are such devastating orphans of weapons for plaintiffs attorneys that a court to certify it as a class. In other words, Brian floors has now suit, on behalf of everyone. Similarly situated now, yes to show that he is an added representatives of the class. I met the claims our common enough that him reference,

the class will be fair to others in that class. Now this is now to be a class of millions or even thousands. Similarly, situated coaches to brain Flores is probably a much smaller group, but nonetheless, a group that would have said mythical power. As a group plaintive and would get into really really significant discovery, far more than it Brian floors and brought this complaint by him. as an individual by breed as a class, you see from the allegations in the complaint they go way beyond Brian floors. They go to wait. Alec an alleged history of Crimination in the NFL, and they may be, get discovery on all of that charges there are going to mourn and those pan out of just for quick. Second, I want to go back to this point about the hit to the reputational brand of the inner fail.

How do you see the relationship between this class action law suit, and then I felt responds to carbon capture Nick, for example, there is a threat that one to draw from Capron it to two: what floor as this is a legit and this point, so how the hell do you think about those two things together at once in this moment?

what Eddie, I think, that's a great question. I think, when you think about what in about has done in terms of trying to show face in the area of social justice in the area of central community, they had the inspire change platform. They have the agreement that they got into with respect to the owners and the players, but any of those things all of those things they never actually took root with a audience that was offended by the way. The comic happily was shut out by the league, even after cabinet had the settlement with the league. There was still a number of people who saw those efforts by the League as window dressing. It's when you add this to come on the back and that it only of problems that distrust, but the public all ready had rather ineffective sincerity with respect to dealing with issues of race and racism within its ranks, and so this is not a thing where people are looking at these, both as isolated incidents, there's absolutely a connection that people are drawing and it has everything to do with interposed credibility, which is why they need to address it and they need to address equipment

our Charles Coleman and Denisov aloes. Thank you both for coming on this morning and coming up said, Joe Mansion, is doubling down on the death of build back better This latest take on what Democrats should do instead and what we Goldberg is off. The view for the next two weeks after comments about the Holocaust, we're gonna, take a look at that I had on morning job dear gets no Some projects need so many parts. It feels like you need a whole storage and just a store them. That's what Ebay is one hundred and twenty two million parts of four think of it, as your virtual arts garage. They always got the right figment at the right prices, use, Ebay, Motors, EP or visit Ebay Motors that come. Let's ride Hayes

same as we gonna pick us. Why is this happening I'll be talking with journalist and author Jonathan cats on his new book? Gangsters of capitalism, if there is a decade, There was gonna radicalized person, it was an eighteen thirty. You got the great depression Capitalism in all of its gross predation has just left people starving and destitute. You ve got the experience of the first World war. very, very clear signs that another world war that is gonna be even worse, is in the offing. This week, unwise is happening. Search for wise is happening wherever using right now and subscribe. Thirty past the hour. The view co host, Whoopi Goldberg has been suspended. Her comments about the Holocaust, Goldberg make the comments on Monday morning, while the panel was discussing a tendency, school board spanning

now say: Pulitzer Prize winning Graphic novel about Nazi death camps, here. Those comments followed by her apology, the next day. Let's be true, about it, because the Holocaust isn't about race. It's not about raise its about what is this about because you it's about man's inhumanity to man. something that I feel are responsibility for not leaving unexamined, because my words of said so many people, which was never. My intention, is indeed about raise, because Hitler and the Nazis considered Jews to be an inferior race words matter and mine are no exception. I regret my comments, as I said, and I stand corrected,

in addition to the apology, the programme brought on Anti Defamation League CEO, Jonathan Green Black, to discuss Goldberg remarks who tweeted afterward deeply appreciate Goldberg. Inviting me on the view today to have an important discussion on the importance of educating about the Holocaust. There has been a long time, ally of the jewish community and the Adsl and her apology very much. Welcome that something we need to talk about this. captains of her apology, which is really important, he asked though the network, suspended Wabi Goldberg for two weeks in a statement. ABC News, President Kim God, when road effective immediately. I am suspending Whoopi Goldberg for two weeks for her wrong and hurtful comments While Whoopi has apologised. I vast to take time to reflect and learn about the impact. Four comments

the entire ABC News Organization stands in solidarity with our jewish colleagues, friends, family and community. How we understand this early? We talk about cancelling culture, all the time, we'll be hasn't, been cancelled, but she's been she's, been suspended. We'll be go. Word makes an offensive statement will be book Goldberg apologises for that offensive statement. We'll be Goldberg. Apologises for anyone who is harmed are hurt, I bet offensive statement. What's he got? Work gets a head the eighty EL on the show to talk more the topic and shed more light on the top and on her mistake we had of the ideal appalled exemptions. What these apology appreciates it and said she has been a long term. Ally.

of the jewish community, so What am I missing here by the way? I was yes what I heard this when I first heard the citizen. What, then, what is she talking about it? She she made. Herbal mistake. We all make terrible mistakes. She poligized forward immediately and to correct actions now I want to know who is so frail over it ABC or who is so frail out there. I can't understand when somebody makes a mistake. Apologises for the mistaken takes all the corrective actions. It Teddy can for that mistake, and then there are still suspend infertile wakes well. Joe, like you, I love I'm a bit baffled. I mean I take it. There might be some pressure behind the scenes from from folks demanding some more concrete consequences for what will be Goldberg set.

but I think is important for us to understand the nature of her confusion. There is this, since that we want to think about, racism as an act of discrimination directed towards some one by one people against other people? it anti right and it often don't we we lose sight of racism as or as in some ways a reflection of white supremacy and how Nazi ISM reflected ideology and put their the confusion happens and Jim James Baldwin wrote about this in an essay entitled negroes ART anti semitic, their anti? Why, indeed, in some ways right innocence, trying to address how Jewishness can morph into whiteness and it becomes very difficult to distinguish and and is a very, very difficult argument to make and weeping? We're going to fill into their minds feel right by the problem is reminiscent end in dumps argument. Jobs are now

but if you're a Jew, it's not really hard to distinguish between being a Jew and being a wise. If you're, a Jew, your people have treated like garbage for thousands of years and even in the Magna Carta, the magnet Which we, we wasps all praise and and festers and praised for you know. Hundreds of years is a great, liberating document yet sickly, said people in England have all of these rights, except for Jews right the property except for Jews happening Anti Semitism has raised any Europe for four for it Centuries anti Semitism wages on college campuses and this country, if you're a Jew on a key. Is an elite colleges if you're a jewelry cap. As you say you, treated differently, sometimes and everywhere you go and by the way, how the people that are alive

today survive the Holocaust. Parents that were, in the whole cause have grandparents that survived I'm sorry, now that we are in a hard to figure out, not use it with a difference between you and a white person, and I don't just suggest that anybody that is trying to draw a difference. But jewels and wasps bags back up and say: yeah the Jews. have actually been persecuted for three thousand years: why don't we look at them? As a separate? ace unless its ways- and we have to be careful when we do have to be careful- must be very clear- that White Superman takes its structure, for Anti Semitism Let us be very, very clear: right: whites, was: he takes its structure from Anti Semitism, which is much older, must be very clear about the part of what remember there is something that will become work said. What is this? Why

a white attacking why people? This is how she said it. There was a line that came out in the discussion, so part of what I'm saying here is: is this that there is a way in which, in the context of american racial hierarchy off times in the interaction between certain communities. There's a kind of whiteness attributed to the jewish population. That can be miss red. That's all I'm trying to say I'm trying to account, for it is very difficult to account for it. I'm not doing it very well this morning, but this is part of the argument, and I think she, this kind of stumbled, as I may be stumbling this morning to Why? Because it so difficult to do, because you know Caddy Kay who There were swore stickers that were or a spray painted union Station Washington D C. This past weekend, there weren't union Jack's their work. get out

flags from Scotland or whatever. You know, Ireland, whatever my heritage is England now there there is. There is an extraordinarily distinct culture and an again Jews are looked at as an inferior, raise by anti Semites by a so so yeah, I again my my my this point was what we apologise and we should just go with that. I think my second point is: people should not go down the trail that will be Goldberg went down because it is a trail that ends up three thousand years of jewish. Seclusion yeah some of the concern about what breeze apology was when she then went on Stephen Colbert and said that the Nazis lied. They had issues with ethnicity city, not with Ray socially kind of seem to double down the idea that it wasn't race having put out that apology and that may Why she's been suspended

two weeks. I'm I'm not sure what you write. What what was the image that really struck cue from Charlottesville when they will walking down with the tricky torches through the town, the white supremacist? It was then more of swastikas and then the two, so they shouted about wanting to get rid of Jews in America and its incredibly powerful. But this way, live in a world where it's very hard to have new all discussions. I think what Eddie was just saying: it is very important in this country because this country's unique history. Racial issues tend to be automatic. we defined as black and white, and I think that's what the argument Whoopi was getting into and was ignoring that there is a very important race. issue that came out of Europe and centuries of persecution. That was the as the Nazis defined it, seeing the juices different race and it's not necessarily just about black and white.

We'll nuanced. Discussions are really important to have and some of the best nuanced discussions come out of mistakes like this, where there's so Learning that could be had so it's too thing that come to my mind, as I I've been watching this unfold over the past. Forty eight hours first of all the education that can be had out of this. The conversations it's been good, the forgiveness, has been important. The learning that has come out of the forgiveness and the learning moments has been. valuable to the audience of the view and we'll be Goldberg No one knows what we wolberg she's, been on tv for decades, she's been putting herself out there for decades, if you don't know her heart, then you haven't been watching, and so that's. the two weeks. Suspensions to me seems more about something else and something

That may be. We need to start putting behind us, which is this. This unbelievable need to punish and judge people can, when they ve made a mistake or when they ve learned something out in the open with the public watching it is for some people to evolve or to make a mistake in front of a national audience. Everyone. on this show, or at least the aspect from self it's happened. very hard. It's horrifying shilling, it's got wrenching, you hate. When you said something: that's hurt, people, it is the worst thing that can happen in a career and so I really feel like, especially at the view where their show is based on arguments there. It's based on debates. It's an the based on making based the moments and their pay to do that hope.

There is some learning for everybody on the show who grow you grace Grange terms of erase into forgiveness in terms of more. Space of kindness. I don't know that may not make us many ratings, but you know this is This is something that is just gonna start getting. Nicholas, I mean it won't be Goldberg cancelled. That would be that would be the I mean that would be the end of this. All this cancel Melcher getting so out of hand there many positives journal. That could happen. This mistake, and instead I feel like tat it in the wrong direction, as you said,

We all know it wasn't mistake. We now get me where were you when you're alive television, you say stupid thing: everybody says stupid things. There ve been sometimes where you now I've said some really stupid things and Willie. His walked out on the tree branch and put his arm come on back big fella Yang ammo. May wonder why don't why don't we go back and the tree and I take it, take it. I'm gonna climate that too, and I just sit there and you can see that Europe is facing the middle of something that you wish to see. What were they in the middle of it? You can see it almost immediately like cut again sort of like you can see Meeker when I started to say things she has look on her face, actually scared for me than Willie. Takes, we home safely gets Gimme the car keys son and We all live happily ever after this, at least until the next segment. Still at inflation is likely decline in the coming months. But what about that

its generated among consumers. We're gonna look in the dynamics of play. Their plus Vladimir Putin wanted NATO troops far away from Russia's borders, but it looks Kazakhs instilling with Ukraine really bringing more next door where things stand right now, and crime in New York City is up substantially compared to this time. Last year we die then, to the numbers and what could be driving the dangerous rise in violence next morning, Joe go beyond the headlines, with MSNBC Daily, a collection of written perspectives to help you better understand the issues of our time. Read now, at MSNBC, dot com