Gainesville, Florida. When John Wayne Hearn posted an ad in Soldier of Fortune Magazine, he was hoping to get a few jobs doing private bodyguard work. He was shocked by the bombardment of calls he received, most of them from people seeking to hire him to murder their enemies, move drugs, or complete other illegal jobs. John ignored them all, until a woman named Debra called him, asking to help intimidate a brother in law as part of a child custody battle. John took the job, and became involved in not one, but three elaborate murder for hire plots, all originating from one source; a woman he loved named Debra Banister.
Get extra episodes from Generation Why at: patreon.com/generationwhy
Listen ad free with Wondery+. Join Wondery+ for exclusives, binges, early access, and ad free listening. Available in the Wondery App. https://wondery.app.link/generationwhy.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
This is an unofficial transcript meant for reference. Accuracy is not guaranteed.
Join wondering plus in the wondering app to listen ad free from wondering
I do doing tonight, I'm doing good. How are you doing I'm doing good
I heard about a weird video online where eighteen it.
Asked for help scorn on with their right there.
Sixteen year old girl. That was a,
she could say being driven
in a car by sixty one year old man, and she was asking for help now.
You know, if you're in a vehicle- and you don't
want to let the person who
I would say, in this case abducted you to know you're, trying to get help the best
you can do is signal for help, and it just so happy
and said, there's been a signal that Tik Tok use
This had been spreading around the violence.
Signal for help and if you look this up on Tik Tok, it's basically you hold up your hand with your thumb across your palm in all.
war fingers up, and then you lower them over the thumb. You trap. The thumb that me
Since you need help, and so this
and is driving and this girl
had gone missing from North Carolina and there was
a person driving along in Laurel County Kentucky
He who noticed this teenager doing the signal for help and because they had
this gesture on Tik Tok. They knew just what it meant and they took it seriously
and called, I believe, the Laurel County Sheriff's office
I'm assuming they came in,
the car over and did a welfare check and figured out
the sky was not her. Father and shouldn't have had her in the car bright and this person had crossed multiple states. His name was James Herbert Brick and he was,
art with first degree unlawful imprisonment. They also found a phone that he had that. Well,
we'll say, allegedly portrayed a girl who was a minor between the age of twelve and eighteen. This is where, to
talk for you know all the people that don't take it seriously if it gets in, know stupid or silly whatever it is. This is something you gotta give credit for, so many people have used
talk for good, and this is just one of those things I'm always happy to hear about. When
something good comes at a social media because I don't think so
media, stupid or childish. I think most of its toxic
and it's it's always good to see things that aren't that way, right as a
story with a red ending. We don't know what would have happened, but for her
like those signals meant she knew she was in trouble and luckily some
was able to help. Furthermore,
if anyone's interest that we do have our own tik Tok, it's at Jan. Why pod there we are
put up videos about upcoming episodes or sometimes just and gives com,
Terry on something or, and one of the things also like that you do and you ve only done it a couple times so far as you give a
behind the scenes commentary about the show about perhaps are original music or whatever else you come up with to talk about and just the other day I actually helped out. Another thought:
stop the vanished with some audio, and I need to make a tick talk about that. Still awesome,
whatever kind of wedding, you're planning, Zola, dot com is the one place to start whatever you need. They ve got your back looking for a wedding venue,
get personalized recommendations in your area in your budget. If you want an amazing gift registry Zola has all the brands you love and some unexpected. Once too, you can create stunning save the dates invites and a matching wedding website, which is why over two million couples have plan their weddings was Zola. So, if you're planning your wedding, ignore those rumours and listen to this Zola is the one place to start: go to Zola dot com today and use promo code, save fifty four
deeper sent off your saved the dates with hundreds of designs to choose from and Easy
simulations, you can start your
putting journey exactly the way you want. A meal
wedding ideas, one place to start: that's Zola Outcome Code, save fifty brought you
Madison Reed seems, like. Everyone is talking about Madison Red lately, Madison Reed is non damaging to hair and has actually been shown to improve the condition of your hair. According to an independent clinical study choose from over fifty five plus gorgeous shades high quality, long lasting hair color made with ingredients, you can feel good about. What's amazed
about Madison, Reed, hair color is that it doesn't smell, I'm not kidding. You know that chemical smell right, that's because it's ammonia free and it's full of ingredients that nourish your hair. Also, you can call or
with an online hair colorist or take their online color. Queers answer a few
actions and the Madison Red colors will recommend the best shades for you. Get ammonia free,
two dimensional hair color delivered to your door, this
Madison Dash red dot com, that's Madison, dash red dot com and now generation. Why listeners get ten percent off plus free shipping on your first color could use code Jen? Why that code again G in W H, why so
nice concern is about
three random murders that laud forcing
have a hard time investigating and they happen somewhat far apart so
They're, not gonna, tie them together and it's a
mystery with love, try
angles and murder.
for higher, which, as you know,
you stand that we ve covered a lot of wives and
has been to hire people to murder their significant others, but typically it turns out that
there, the hiring an FBI agent or something to that effect, and in this case, though, they ve,
somebody who was truly a hitman with that. What are we talking about tonight
night were talking about the case of John Wayne Hearn? Who, because
he had gotten a bit older and was no longer employed in the military decided. He wanted new adventure
the new employment, new opportunities and decided to play some ads in
soldier of Fortune magazine offering his services, but the calls he got the requests that he got. Let him down a different path,
I think. Even he was expecting
then that name John Wayne Hearn mean
the only other John Wayne. You know as well as the middle name is John Wayne Gacy, so Mama,
don't let year, babies grow up to be named John Wayne, anything good advice. This takes place in
Phil Florida for the most part? And then
Is the mid eighties Justin, my favorite time, those with a good days right,
like good music out, then there was good music.
I don't know what were you listening to and the media is Justin
Most part, I listen to a lot of the scent pop kind of stuff,
the typical eightys, which was like flies
seagulls and Deronda, ran neo,
in my language, Duran Duran. They just came out the new album, its phenomenal, but
I will say that by the Ladys I had discovered
industry, Austria in skinny, puppy and metal
her metal who metals and that same. But
in this case just we all know how these things occur. It's because people,
start to resent or have a problem with their say,
to others or boredom. I think we'll get to that. But that's really the set up here. So let's talk about the the victims, you talked about
these murders- it was January sixth, nineteen
Five Cecil baby was thirty, three years old,
He was shot through the front window of his home. While he slept on the couch now,
if any one word it just put that now
in front of me, I would say well, it was either a dry by shooting where they were just shooting, randomly or
It was a stray bullet that enter
the home and hit somebody that was asleep like this couldn't have been intentional butter Cecil.
What happened to be involved in a custody battle with
Marlene sense at the time of his death that suck about this.
Steady battle, though Marleen was
his former wife,
and so they were involved in this
the battle, and it was pretty heated, neither one wanted to give ground. So this was really just you could say, a person of interest for the police but tat. I may
She has done this
It seems random enough, so there
next murder was the murder of Joe.
Anna Stir, it was close to them.
Thirty p m on February sect.
Ninety five, when the brain
County sheriff's office received a call
Vietnam, one reporting a car crash. This was in a drainage. Ditch
most stretch of highway, so
officers were despatched and they found Joe banners
Who was forty one at the time gist
dead behind the wheel is car. He was slumped over the wheel, delights lights is motor
was running and it looked like. The car hedges either been.
off the road or driven off the road he was
eating from the head, so they thought maybe he had hit
head during the accident right, they attempted CPR
to save his life, but they couldn't revive him and they knew who he was because they found his driver's license and he was pretty much intact
wasn't, really any damage to obscure his face so because they
who thought they were assigned to an accident, they are taking their time
they're looking around at the vehicle, but they
really see how this vehicle would have been pushed off. The road or anything that
was pretty much intact, so
they're like this, isn't the kind of accident that would cause someone step there looking up
vehicle, they notice that the drivers side window is shattered, but
there's no collision or anything this. Let's another
something else probably happened. So
looking all over and they keep confirming what they thought originally way.
This isn't look like an accident,
that's when they send his body off to the morgue and they will have an autopsy done,
at one twenty. The morning officer Winston Barber drove over to Deborah Ban.
Stars house, Jos, wife, to give her the bad news that her husband instead and Deborah broke down. She said
my husband and I we drove separately to a friends house for dinner and I left well before he died.
So then she asked him whereas Joe, where did you find it?
He said? Well, we found him in his vehicle in a ditch
and that his body was sent to the morgue for an autopsy and she didn't want him
to have an autopsy done. She didn't want his body cut up.
He said, while it's procedure, and now it's not your call February.
First nineteen, eighty five, a man
and by the name of Bob Black arrives
after running errands
and his son is the first one to go inside the home and he makes a terrible discover
hurry. He finds said his mother has been shot to death.
These are the three murders in this case and, of course, be
as each of these individuals had been shot, but in different circumstances,
nothing really that connects them. As far as
Instigation goes: that's where you need a lot.
Work, and you need some luck tat. Something is
he has so the
active is told Deborah Banister about
her husband's death and he's gotten a little push
back about the autopsy but
February third tat. They get the autopsy results and, as they suspected Joe didn't die in a car crash. He died from two gunshot wounds.
One to the back of his head, which was like a grazing wound and then another one to the side into his brow.
Killing him instantly. So once again, the officers need contact, Deborah they're, telling
Your husband was shot to death, but
She has a weird question: she wants to know what the caliber of the weapon was that killed her husband.
Then I would say that would be the last question on my mind, if I heard about my husband or wife being shot, I would want to know
where who and what are you doing about it, but not kind of Gunnar? What
caliber where they killed with that's just weird.
Well, everyone react differently right,
just two days later that the wrapper county
Sheriff's office got a call from it.
Skaters at the ALA Tewa County Sheriff's office. This is,
The office s investigating the murder of Cecil Baby, who we talked about already.
This is because officers that were investigating Cecil babies murderer were kindness,
specious of Marlene Sims. It's the only real
led the had because of the custody battle we talked about now they became more
suspicious when, on February, seventh Larry Foster, who
Merlin sims third husband came ended.
the police that he feared for his life and he told the police about US
vicious man that had been hanging out with me,
sister, Deborah
It's her older sister, Deborah Ann eating,
the main name, John Wayne Hearn. That's a good led for them:
who is this John Wayne heard there he's referring to? Well, that's something
we'll get into an a bit
thing is, is Larry had spent
with the police and then, after that, he and his wife got it
an argument any
hidden head pretty hard. They said he
skull injury now more
he said he hit me,
she ran over him trying to escape Larry. Didn't
we recall what happened but
his family insisted that Marleen hit him intentionally so
the fall out here is that Larry Foster he's partially
line after being hit. That, of course, the district attorney speaking to the media
called it very suspicious, but now
They have a name Justin and the
and who had given him, the name may have been almost killed
they want to follow up on this John Wayne, Hearn Guy and here's the weird thing. Never banister went to her husband's funeral
and she was accompanied by a man who she was.
Producing as her long lost cousin, but
Jos family. They didn't buy it. They know
her this guy. They were watching them and they were thinking. That's not a cousin. They also said
to the investigators and Bradford County in this cousin was
being weird at the funeral. He was acting like the life of the party and he wouldn't leave Deborah side,
this latter red flags there? So investigators
look into John Wayne Hearn they find out. He was a thirty eight
old, Vietnam veteran who had worked as a truck driver. He had for
previous marriages and lived in a studio apartment near Atlanta.
He was having a custody battled zone over his son, who lived with his mom in South Carolina
he had been investigated by the Georgia Bureau
investigation in the past because he had placed
adds in soldier of Fortune magazine. As you know, this is something that the different bureaus
keep an eye on cuz in the back.
magazine, there's the classifieds, and
you'll get some really interesting stuff back there, especially in a soldier of Fortune magazine and
being that he's.
Now that the war is over,
He doesn't have a lot going on in his life.
to be kind of a loner can't keep a relationship or a marriage together, I'm sure he's too
to figure out a way to feel more important
He really is and that's why,
decided to put ads in the back of this.
magazine and
depending on where you read, or what you see that this case, some of them are more or less. I will do bodyguard work
security work for you for a couple hundred
today, too I'll do dirty deeds done dirt cheap. Just
the OECD Seesaw now these,
if they don't have that, do they just and now it's probably,
because of this case now? It is because this case so back and said
a of nineteen. Eighty four is, when John,
and heard paid forty bucks for an ad to appear
in an issue of soldier of Fortune Magazine, the ad red X, marine,
sixty seven, sixty nine NOM vat acts D. I weapon specialist jungle warfare. Higher
assignments. U S or overseas now. Why would he placed it in that magazine? Justin? That's your target, demographic
it's a it's a gun magazine. It's a soldier magazine its everything that
mainly men want to read about military news right. Yes and most of the reader,
back then, were Vietnam veterans and
magazine allowed readers supposed these personal service adds back in the day and well, apparently,
John Hearn was getting multiple calls a day. Now he's not the
the person to put ads in the magazine. Of course, that's why they had it may now it was available, but yeah it was said.
He was getting three to five calls a day and
These requests were for contract killings.
For transporting drugs, weapons, even assaults and
John Wayne will say that he
in reply to any of them, except for when a woman wrote in
this was Deborah banister. The we
thing is is Deborah has said
friend things at one point Shiva said she met John Wayne Hearn for the first time before she ever met Joe Banister, but there's
Then the happens when they meet sparks fly and
John Wayne Turn is in love, love at first sight and apparently dab.
This guy's a lot more exciting. Then her current husband,
so Marleen sends was subpoenaed theatre
is wanted her to do an interview. This was for
were a nineteen eighty five, while she
come alone. She came along with her elder sister, Deborah and when the day
active, ass, Marleen about the night that are
husband was murdered. She said that Deborah left her children with her. While she and Joe went to dare so kind of banana, what an alibi
yeah and because debars right there, the police want to talk to her to and
say that there was about an hour difference between Deborah Ann Marlins statements about, went Deborah, picked up the kids, so there's a dust
I can see there a red flag if he will
Deborah also said that John Hearn wasn't her cousin, because I asked about him.
yeah. That's what she had told everyone at the funeral, but she didn't tell detective that she said he's a friend there's no romance here. Not there might that I'm in Sheep
really put him out an arms reach its on February thirteenth, the owl
you have sheriff's office, brought job
Herndon for an interview, and he was talking to that
actors about his
add in soldier of fortune and that he could make
the three dollars a day doing private bodyguard work when they
asked him about his relationship with Deborah Banister. He said
strictly platonic, he again kind of distance himself,
from her saying you know we're just friends dont know,
other that well. But when ask him
Where were you on February? Second, he says
that he was with his mother and South Carolina, while the detectors
ago, speak to his mom Mary Watson, Johns mother, at that local police station
and she verified jaunts alibi and they asked her
Deborah Banister and she said she,
had no idea who Deborah was so that detective stepped out of the interrogation room, and
saw young boys sitting in the waiting room and he goes
so the boy goes here. Who are you,
who, as one you know, sort of sun
Ok you're Johnson is like. Are you from
Florida, and they sparkled
it'll conversation and
The sun said that he had saw Mickey mouse the previous weekend,
he's psycho. Who were you with him? He said
my dad John, my new mom and dad.
like your new Mamma and he pulled out a pitcher of Deborah said,
this your new mommy and, of course the son, said yeah at that
why the investigators had caught the mental. Why and
They knew that there was a lot more going on between Deborah Ann John at that,
Watson Johns mother was covering for them and this all contradicted Johns alibi by the way
take moment get a word from our sponsor. Sir Flint. I ordered a pair of the Natalie Flats with leopard print their super cute.
it's because these issues are designed by women and actually made for women to walk in, but it should not
taken this arm for someone to realise a pair of designer shoe
that are going to last for years should actually be comfortable enough to wear and can actually look
as great as any other designer shoe. I didn't know that
did you, ladies? This is why
obsessed with Sarah Flint shoes. Sarah Flint is a woman designing shoes for women, which is why her timeless footwear
offers style without sacrifice, you get great looks quality, and this is the key comfort in Sarah Flint shoes. You see small details like extra padding, a wider toolbox or insel shape to support your foots natural arch, the best part, Sir flat cost hundreds less than other designer brands, their priced direct consumer, no middle man, no markups, you pay for quality and nothing else. For a limited time. You can get up the two
dollars off your surf lent purchase, get fifty dollars off your first pair and save up to two hundred on multiple pairs of shoes. The more you by the more you save a special offer fur generation. Why listeners that Sarah Flint Dotcom Flash gin? Why, for up to two hundred dollars off one more time, Sarah Flint
calm, Slash G and W H. Why were also by
Dubai? Sleep number? The holiday season is Festival fund, but also can be stressful, give shopping DEC
hosting travelling all takes its toll. That's why you need quality sleep, its essential to boost energy
and your overall well being lack asleep, can leave you feeling Scatterbrain anchored
key, especially ram holidays. Nobody wants that in, for me, lie
sleep can have an adverse effect on my memory, and I care
amber all those details about evidence in the court case. I really gotta be on top of my game. That's why I sleep on my sleep number bet. I sleep
queue up. Let me know how well I'm sleeping at night tells me when I'm restless and gives me an overall score last night
that seventy six, but I got a stick to a regular routine. I can't be distracted by my phone or social media have to go to bed at roughly the same time every night, and I
my exercise and fresher every day. I can't say enough good things,
sleep number? It's the bed, I'd chosen for the last ten years of my life
discover new offers now, for a limited time at your look
Sweden of restore or sleep number dot com slashed gin. Why sleep number
and quality sleep. His life changing sleep. So now this detective
ass some ammunition. When he goes back into that interrogation room. Does he not?
absolutely
and he goes back in
threats talking to marry Watson and says hey.
I know you lied to me and
investigating this murder, so I'm gonna go
and charge you with conspiracy to commit murder. If you don't cooperate,
unless she say that her Mary Watson she broke down and she
came clean about her sons alibi. She said that they were
together on that night and then she, even
one step further in which this is weird to me. But back
nineteen eightys we
have we
to know, did you
they record a phone call. We had
things called the answering machines back then
had a cassette tape and she apparently had recorded
phone calls between John and Deborah
and she hands over these tapes and that's it
weren't, you know she. She handed over tapes, multiple tapes,
and this is where she was proud.
We wrestling with do I
for my son, or do I talked to the police in
Give up anything. I know because if he's blue
but also what he's doing is wrong and they
threatened her with a conspiracy subpoena right, but I just but I dont think she would have had these tapes
give to them. If she wasn't at least considering doing the right thing, I get what you're saying they forced her hand away yeah, but
and she she could have just not had those,
speaking with that she was really all inopportune
dinner son. True, she could just came clean
the alibi, but providing them with all this
evidence of their relationship there affair.
Even then,
spiralling to commit murder. Any
apes are damning, I mean not only do they get the clearer picture of what was going on between Deborah Ann
John professing, their love for each other, but also they have it on recording that Deborah is giving
details about her husband schedule, so they can put
together. So what?
still Mary give them a photocopy
of a one thousand dollar check made out to her son. He added
to her address and the church
was, from our man
named Bob Black who lived in
Ryan, Texas so
DE detectors, contacted the brain.
Police department and the author
there's there said that Sandra Black
had recently been gone down in her home
unknown assailant so just in,
who incidents. What must this feel like what must have been
like when they have three different homicides and they have one name connecting them all. This is paid her.
This is where they really had on something big here, because without this term
events of them going down the right roads that they could have missed at all. If the detective hadn't just stopped by
and talked to the sun in the waiting room, this whole case could have gone differently. Also,
John Wayne Hearn had just committee
these murders and taken off
you have been long gone, but
John Wayne Hearn was her in love with them,
so he wasn't going anywhere. The other things
here is that, since the officers have this named John Wayne, Hearn Marleen Deborah no, they know of him.
Now their concern that time is running out. So
tell Mary Watson, you better get hold of your son and tat the term self in for his own safety, because
we don't know what's gonna happen and, of course
worried that Marlene Deborah may plot to kill him because well, if he
taken in, he talks there really in trouble what happens March. Fifteen nineteen, eighty five
well John Wayne Hearn, has turned himself into the police in Texas
it's weird catches.
item in custody for several days, and he can. I gave them sort of
Rigour Moreau over a story
He ended up telling them everything he told them.
Had it all started when he was looking for work, he was placed
ads and soldier of fortune and receive
ten to twenty calls a day
He says that it was in October of eighty four that Deborah Banister contacted him. They agreed to meet
She was so young and attractive. He just fell in love.
met at a Shoney's, big boy, restaurant, I remember those and I miss them in Georgia.
Ever told him. She wanted some one to intimidate her sisters, Ex husband, Cecil baby.
This is where it all comes full circle, the ashes,
hoping that, with his pressure that sea, so it
fuck off
Dad Marleen would get custody of her kids now and this
something that's reported in every
every story. You read about this case, but at the end of that meeting that first meeting between Deborah John she kissed
on the nose, and he just completely fell in love with her
this is a guy that was down on his luck, all the
I've been in his life is over and now he's
attention from this woman and
able to do things for her and make her happy and get paid is on top of the world.
He said how he made plans to relocate to gains fell and when they pulled up phone records they found
there were thirty seven calls from Deborah to John between.
October of eighty four in January of eighty five, many. Finally,
to Florida, so there is the problem now to have someone killed the least typically
it costs money. Doesn't it just in and we ve heard of cases per you can pay so
a few hundred box, but
his case. The request was forthwith
a thousand dollars but of course Deborah her sister. They don't have that kind of money and their true
to negotiate with
John Wayne Hearn
Of course, when he's
A crush on her is, is gonna come down and he apparently doesn't know is worth so they up agreeing to.
ten thousand dollars, and this is after she changed her request.
from intimidation to murder, now yet understand
not so much. He doesn't understand his worth. I think it's because he sleeping with this woman, so maybe
he gets a discount right. It's a third of the
and cost ten thousand and apparently
wasn't even Deborah. They got him to bring the number down, but I think
think she has something to do with it. What we hear, though, is
her mother. I
a Sims is the one that to say: please bring the costs down, so we can afford this
the whole families and on apparently now. Yet
have to raise the money some way because they don't even have ten thousand dollars right. So Iris and her husband, Frank decide to invite her mother
the grandmother in the family down for a visit to gain spill yeah. She agrees to it and apparently Deborah
meant it wouldn't be a shame if grandma's house burn down while she was an gains fell, so she
down for Thanksgiving and when she arrived Deborah, Marleen, basically headed
out of the house drove five hours to go, burn third grandmothers house down: they broke
the house, any apparent least varnish remover in the house and then set it on fire
DA, they arrived home
stay now,
police or suspicious, because while this grandmother had left town
for fifty years, so what was the luck that she leaves home for the first time at fifty years and her house burns down
yet that insurance policy and get a bunch a lump sum of money Dasso. This insurance money came through on January. Second, ninety five, so what you're saying Aaron as they could have afforded the thirty thousand well we'll get into this? But the insurance money came through an
next day, Marlene CALL John, who was back in Atlanta and they agree
me at a motel and gains fell. The next day she paid him
his? Ten thousand in one hundred dollar bills- and he is three hundred dollars of that- to purchase a shotgun Marleen
when over two or Ex Husband House, Cecil Baby, to pick up her kids and
stole a box he's so use the store insurance papers. I wonder why
here's some information that comes through John sure he was being told, he'll be paid handsome.
We are right to murder Cecil Baby, but he actually drove
ass House housed, Weiss thinking, he wasn't gonna do it, but he drove by
third time and finally stop
the car and got out and he walked up to the
now now remember you'd, you talked about an earlier, you were saying, seem so random yeah. Well for him, it is
lock because there were Cecil just there inside the window, there
he was able to shoot him and then get out of their real quick. He probably thought why don't leave any evidence?
general seventh night. Eighty five Marleen
Cecil's insurance agent, but she was told
sorry, but you aren't listed as a
Fishery of this thirty thousand dollar life. Insurance policy
imagine how happy she was to hear that, so now they have to
John yeah, we don't really have your money yet to pay for Cecil's murder. Jammed is glad that this
go so poorly for them. It's such a cluster of
a situation and Deborah had
aims for some the money too, because she went to use some of the money to build the dream.
The home for the two of them
be together, have a happy life,
even opened a joint bank account where Deborah sign her name is Deborah Hearn
Do you know how John son called Deborah Mommy? Well, devereuxs kids were calling John Daddy Bottleneck
There were some more information about how John targeted Joe and it was because Deborah left the party
an hour before Joe did so all job
had to do, was wait for Jos vehicle to come along Pino. It even
for Joe came along John.
stop Deborah you because he stopped her. She was driving through the area and he made sure
she really wanted this done and she said you know get on with it. Basically
no remorse, no second thoughts. You know
trying to say that John Sis, pure of heart, guy, that's being put into this tough situation. I'm just saying of all the people involved he's the only one that seems to have second thoughts. Now he still carry
The murders don't get me wrong. He stole a murderer, but I'm saying
interesting that he's trying to tell Marleen he's trying to tell Deborah do they want to think about this of all more know, it's almost
after that, first one once they gotta a taste for it. There all bets are off. Now we want this. Man was working in their favour,
and John said when he spotted Jos car. It was about eleven at night, but there is too much traffic.
Well, I'm you know shoved the view
off the highway as it were, so he got his gun and fire.
Joe down a country road and that's when he
up alongside and shot him twice, but you know because
as of like what you're saying where they got a taste of it well
do these two murders Deborah
John. You should do this more often because
its brain money off course, and that's went Bob Black contacted him in January of eighty five but
the first time John turned him down Madeira,
now. You can't turn this down. Bob Black also was a Vietnam veteran and he read soldier of fortune in. I was expect
at this point for John Hearn too, maybe push back a little harder because
he had been murdering men, but now
is being asked to murder a woman, and I guess,
watch too many movies. Where there's this code, you know no women, no children, but now John, he seems to go ahead with. It
and looking into what happened with Sandra Minute. But this thing that's really significant about this is John, didn't accept this offer from Bob Black until he walked out of the sheriff's office after the first interview, so he was being questioned by the authorities,
and then he was released and that's when he went and key
Bob and said I right to take the job,
that's where that thousand dollar cashiers check came from whose Adam
payment and there is also a hand written note. If there
anyway, you could schedule your plans. To conclude with me,
being alibis out of town this weekend. It would help considerably and here's the thing Bob lack he was having an affair. It was with his first cut.
And he promised John ten thousand dollars to kill Sandra Black, his wife and hears here
That's really awful. He said that his wife's really only failing,
was that she was slow
Lee Overweight? Have you
read that anyway, you want its decision
gets worse and worse now? Here's the thing before Sandra
was to be killed. Bob talk to her and said
and I want to get a new life insurance policy going. So we
her sign and pay for a new one hundred thousand our life insurance policy wow through the wood,
like there's so much, there's so much
portrayal here, it's it's a joke. Almost now Bob met up with John at his home,
they needed to stage the scene, so would look like a robbery. This is why so
Your died she just now
be home when there was
robbery and she was killed so mob. Of course, left.
Home, so he'd have an alibi and John waited,
ambush her when she got home from work here
in the dining room and when
got in there. He stuck up behind her and shot in the head
and this is something I think is now- if you're looking for how this gets worse, Bob Black intentionally sent his son in first so that he would discover his mother dead. Weight of
who in a kids life, but when you're
hiring contract killers to murder your wife, then I guess you don't really have that many morals anywhere. So we talked-
John Hearn had fallen for Deborah he loved her
this is obviously one of the reasons he was commend these murders, but it was after Sandra, was murdered. The Deborah too,
did John and said we need to break up.
You need a runaway also Deborah
decided. She wanted to try and sell some of Sandra Blacks jury. So you,
Tell me John tried to do every could fur Deborah, and this is how she thanks him. The but once
Deborah gets wind of John
mother being
question by the police that spooks her and she a meal
the cuts things offered with John and Bob Black. Well course he wants to go
The life insurance money, the hundred thousand dollars
but he doesn't really have any time to talk to the police about his wife's murder, the authorities they have this case put together.
There is really no mystery at this point. They ve got
of interviews done. They have the recordings, they have the confession from John Hearn, Deborah Deborah Banister,
Merlin sims were arrested April fifteen nineteen. Eighty five Deborah was chow.
urged in connection with Cecil's murder, along with Marleen, Frank and irish Simms.
Says the family. They appeared in court, Jus knife nineteen, eighty five-
for they can ever go to court, though Marleen gotta play deal
in every of ninety six. She pleaded no contest to conspiracy to come
first degree, murder and arson. Her sentence five and a half years in prison Deborah also pleaded. She pleaded no
contest conspiracy to commit first degree, murder and received thirty years. Frank and Iris pleaded no contest to being accessories after the fact and received five years, probation, so whole family
down so Deborah had pleaded no contest, in the case
the murder of Cecil baby. But when it came to her husband, Joe Banister, well, she went to trial and what happened to trial Justin
this time round, her
but I was looking at
long jail sentence and she was too
The fine trial about her affair with John Hearn and she denied ever planning
kill her husband but John.
Pretty much
on against her at this point, mainly because, once she cut him off
He had nothing to lose and
they had all of the tapes from his mother. So things were
looking good for her during the trial, she wanted the jury to know
that she met John Hearn at a truck stop in seventy eight. That's before she moved to Florida, Mary Joe Banister, and she talked about meeting John again in December of eighty four to get away from home and think but she's
setting this up as yeah. There wasn't
air which on Hearn, but I didn't plot to kill my husband, so she tried to put it off on John, but the jury didn't buy and
think that's because the jury believe John Her, because he testified against her
she would end up being found guilty of second degree murder in Rio
to Joe banisters death. She has
for ten years. So, even though
on and Deborah are pointing the finger
at each other, he said
that she's, the masterminds she's, the one that hired have all these things,
John is still enamored by her
John is still in love with her, and there is a moment.
during trial, where she's fiddling with the ring.
Yes, that he bought for her and after
after the hearing was over. He was brought
into one of the lawyers thing. Did you see she was Fit
with the ring, she was showing me that she still cared about me. It's it's pathetic
It really is the black family
files, a lawsuit against soldier of Fortune magazine because of them allowing this add to run and that it basically precipitated the
murders aspire?
we have Sandra Black, so John
testified on October thirteen nineteen
Eight and a deposition, any talked about
calls he received after posting ad and even getting a request for a political assassination. Now he claimed that he met four different vietnam.
Europe needs me, name them as Don Jeff David and Warren and said that he had higher
them to carry out assignments and was going to accept a wreck?
as to bomb the organ commune
He does
in the end that the com, you was too heavily armed and it wasn't worth the risk, but
the magazine, their defence team,
seated that the ad brought these
together, but they incur
did, that the publisher
didn't know. The ad was for illegal activity.
the admit just ten. They can have a boy. You know I mean you can look at that.
Does. It really say I'll, kill people now, but I mean what would they expect right, but is this enough to cover for them? That's a question
I guess I think of a more modern time when they went after back page or
craigslist categories and said that it was human trafficking when there were
port services or private, massage services being offered, and they went after those websites for
those activities- and this is very similar when they're going after soldier soldier of fortune, so the families- a turning the blacks family attorney, said that, because of this
is he NAD, Kern murder? Three people in forty five days
her and agreed with thy said if, if they had was never run, he wouldn't have killed anybody. The jury found soldier
Fourchan magazine liable for Sanders death and ordered them to pay now,
in point: four million dollars to Sandra Surviving Sun and mother. Does podcast sponsored by
help online therapy, it's the holidays. I know that
be rough for a lot of people, maybe you're eating healthy all year round, but then Thanksgiving
must come around you're, not gonna. Keep on your game. Psych sticking
to an exercise routine. It's like sticking to a diet, it's going
and getting your car maintenance going to therapies
like all the above, its routine maintenance for your mental and emotional wellbeing going to therapy
doesn't mean something's wrong with you. It means you're in,
asking in yourself to keep your mind healthy, better help is customized
mine therapy that offers videophone and even
live chat sessions with your therapist. So you don't have to see any one on camera if you don't want to its much more affordable than in person therapy- and you can start
indicating with your therapist in under forty eight hours, wine
in anything else and not your mind generation. Why listeners get ten percent off their first month at better help dot com, Slash Jen? Why that's better help be
TT? Are eighty lp dot com?
I generally ma Black went to trial John. Her
has to fight against him said that Bob first met
to discuss, selling a gun collection, but after a few conversations he requested help in killing his wife's name
We don't really need to go through any more details on this. This is an open and shut case
have the murderer testifying. So what else can you do? Bob black found guilty of cap
murder he was sentenced to death and executed. May twenty third. Ninety ninety two at the Texas State prison at the age of forty five,
I've and that's why you don't mess taxes? Speakers are higher
you hit. Man gets you the death sentence and he had to.
To save his own life down. His appeal was
an argument that PTSD was response,
for all this, but yeah that didn't
them. No one bought that story. They said there
way too much planning involved, he was to deter
to do this. I think the PTSD. What would our work better if he hadn't hired someone else to do the job exactly that
that's not how that works, and I but the devil.
hence in anyone's gotta, defend themselves. However, they want yes, but there were people at the time who knew by Black who said that he,
comments that he wished. He could kill his wife, but
He couldn't do it himself now this
soldier of fortune lawsuit where they
ended up having to pay nine point four million dollars well yeah that didn't end up working out because a nineteen eighty nine a federal appeals court throughout the award and said that the verdict
I was to higher standard on them,
his. I take that
mean that that add, as it was yeah, they didn't reach the three:
told where you could prove that. That's what it meant, and
a similar thing happened in the back page and craigslist adzes. They want
after them hard for that stuff. But then, when it was all said and done, it was hauled. Trot. Debbie
Banister was released from prison. Two thousand for Joy
Hearn remains incarcerated in
Carolina now actually looked up his his page. You know you can look up prisoners
pages on the internet.
I being everything from
they ve been what their incarcerated for, and it seems like lately he's made. A few trips
way to other locations for medical reasons now some people feel like
since Deborah was so deeply involved. In these cases
that. She basically got off light.
Machines, no longer imprison Scott now
in this case. With any end, this was
mid, delayed eighties when they went to trial. Do you think of it
different if she were sense today
sure, just because
there are so many different factors and variables
depends on the prosecutor. Depend
on the judge and depends on. If there were any plea deals. I think that I would want to think doubts.
would have gotten a longer sentence today, but
sure yeah think she did get
variable sentencing. I definitely believe that she was involved in pretty much every step of this, but now you're right. It's up to the prosecutor. It's up to the district attorney
this isn't always bear, but the important thing
as no matter how many times John Hearn asked are
sure he definitely needed
be put away for life. This is
someone you want loose as it now. Absolutely not. I mean
I am sure that he might have put those ads in the back a soldier
Fourchan with better.
tensions, but as soon as
calls started coming in. I think this gave him some sense of purpose.
some sense of excitement- and it was going to,
Go this direction, no matter what and nobody twisted his arm. Nobody
forced him to do this at gunpoint. He
Is the source of all of this violence
I would say, is that where we ve already kind of alluded to it is, I think he wouldn't.
Have done all this. If he didn't fall in love with her, he made it up
I to say that he had turned down Ali
offers prior to meeting Deborah. Let's
again you have people who you get the right to people together. Things happen. They you never thought possible,
never miss an episode of generation. Why subscribe to us on Apple podcast, Spotify, Cast box or reverie listening right now, also
sure to follow us on social media. Our tik Tok is at GEN. Pod are in
Graham is at generation. Why podcast join wondering, plus in the wondering, app to listen ad free?
a verbal we have vacation arms for you and whoever you got family and by family,
the interest mean shared DNA like parents and cousins and grandma we mean child
France during the meal teammates
during a joke. It's yours,
the girls? We gander guys sharing tough love sharing time with the people who make you realize
important. Family is
Why you need a place to be run for about a place for together down
They have to find a worse
Transcript generated on 2022-02-27.