Today's episode has brought you buy Stillwater from focus features, starring, Matt, Damon and directed by Tom Mccarthy. Only in theatres July thirtieth still, water is the most powerful motion picture of the summer. Matt Damon Place Bill Baker, a blue collar worker from Oklahoma, who must travel to Marcin France to exonerate, has a strange daughter from a murder charge secrets run deep Stillwater in theatres July Thirtieth Obama cure. A disaster and I actually do have a replacement by Lookit. I just read about it this week Riddick Plan, just great. It's called the afforded here s the same thing as Obamacare, and if you appeal it, twenty million people will lose their health insurance. I mean people could die mission's report.

president rule moments like those enough to trigger the former president into wanting the Justice Department, Justin The ESA now from him, my God, will tell you about that were morning just ahead good morning and welcome to morning Joe this Wednesday June, twenty third, along with Joe Willie and may we have lessened Missy contributor, MIKE Barnacle in New York and here Washington calmness. Ten associate editor for the Washington Post, David Ignatius New York Times, Washington, bureau, Chief Elizabeth Bill Miller, national political report for actions. Jonathan Swann, Why house, correspondent for, but and co author of the Playbook Eugene Daniels is also an MSNBC contributor good to have you all, I'm great, haven't we're not you're. Really, you all had a mares rise up in Gotham. There was

there's rates. There's no talk of suing ass, an AL or having they react off the air from mean impersonations. They may have done. But yes, there, the vote was in bed, have been cats in the primary raise for New York City Mare, but we're not getting over a couple weeks who one I'll stipulate that the ranch Its voting system prevents us from telling you the one exactly, but for now we know that former police cap in New York, city, police officer, Eric Atoms, the early leader with thirty. Two percent of the first choice vote trailing are former council to make the blog your Maya, wily she's at twenty two percent in former city, sanitation, commissioner Catherine Garcia with twenty percent of the vote. Fourth place goes to twenty twenty presidential candidate Andrew Yang. Who early in this race, but who can see it last night on the republic inside Guardian Angel Founder Curtis Cely were frozen, five years on the republican primary. So he moves on to the general election, but we were

not we'll get into some of these numbers and what happens next, because it is a little bit confusing about who still could win if it's not nourish atoms, we're getting those numbers in just a minute: yeah yeah, New York, in anybody here in New York. Telling you I'm telling you laid. If We can legislators tried it concoct a voting system like New York. Cities like New York stays man and it would be like Jim Crow. A boy now is a ass up their Eugene and it always is children twenty twenty election. I gotta come friends and it say how to get the girl line for like eight hours. I've been waiting to do this. For four years, I'm about to go home, it's a mess up there, either from every, but anybody

some people in New York. Are you talking about the voting you're talking about and that's what's with the rank twice this very confusing the radical out of them through a lot of people in that something that would you at any? In all of these conversations about voting make me easier, but that's not what what's happened in New York is democratic stronghold, but it also doesn't matter because the primary pics exactly and unwilling we're not going to die for like two, I'm sorry, I with a straight face. I recently haven't like a big geographic area where you have a lot of time for the mail and bows Yet in long to get today, Staten Island, you know midtown very river running stories years ago, when I was a metro porter further times about the energy defend, defend chest go. Who was the day problems back twenty years ago, There are still problems well too.

Like it's gonna take two weeks for them to figure out who won a marriage race in one city may be longer than that. It may be MID July before they actually know, because now the next Tuesday is when they start Reallocate those boats in the rank choice. They look at that mail in voting. They look at the absentee voting makes oh, yes, it will be a while, but will be interesting to see how this shakes at this is first in our country, obviously, for a city or neglect this size to use rank choice, boating source or learning as we go, the oil Willie I was walking around yesterday, largely in the upper West side, but parts of Midtown Manhattan. I suspect that I was looking at classic case of voters. Suppression, that's what this I rang choice that voting. I mean there or longer lines at the bakery that I go to them. There were four people voting. I didn't want to turn out ended up being, but I suspect it was pretty well

fairness, Joe might goes to magnolia, basically, which is very popular and always has aligned, also unfairness, when might start to sentence. By saying, I was just why, yes, to always gives our call that now day, is ending in a war zap late last night at eleven thirty, those great so red Sox, where that's crazy is so you had a greener bad. Yesterday I mean it

depressing Ipad when it is not. I think it is important that talking about Afghanistan who could have seen coming if we let them know we were going to retreat and get out of what I said that I tell him what actually take advantage evident start, killing people left and right show. It's happened so quickly. Present Biden announced back in April that he'd be pulling all. U S, troops, not many left. Twenty five hundred by September eleven and across the country that has just been a domino effect more than fifty districts of fallen since May one, and there is a sense in Afghanistan now talking to or friends there a real demoralization thee, fear is the full scale, so world will break out again, I quoted a woman who runs a women shelter. I was just thinking about the women fled for sick Taliban a battering.

and again the hiring- and these are the women we ve- been telling sense since early two thousand to go to school. These good job of women who are going to protect that they not safe, was bringing a new era to Afghanistan who believed in it lived at the now are litter on the run, trying to find someplace. That's that safe present, Ashraf, guarding the present government of get. A stand, such as it is, will be in washing Friday those present Biden so by one second restocking change solace, easy. There is very little left to do it's too late, and that is why these situations, where it really is to lay down the troops runaway out every week, said, come sons. Other press release saying what percentage of all equipment sky it's basically what are the options? Are there any options so make the only option left really are financial support that will give them later by the

the higher the contractors keep their military in the air which the most important thing and then diplomatically It turns out that every country that matters does not want to talk about the take over in Kabul, Russia, China, IRAN, Pakistan, every single country, Greece itself. It is somewhat it bring them other more forcefully say no

product. They don't want it enough. They don't want it around they're, not gonna committee. I was I was in Pakistan last week. I interviewed Prime Minister Enron time by way of your family's going to Islam about this week in these posters of Jonathan up, and you can't we'd exactly what's under leave that phase, it's probably remain on. The rapid is a few things so David's exactly right. This is where is heading there very worried com was talking about a civil war that seems to be bought everyone's expecting. The idea that you can be coerced the Taliban into a peace settlement seems like a pipe dream right now. Why would they may have all the cards? Matthew? S has no leverage they're out and the idea that the other thing you sometimes evenly boys. You know it's not your father's Taliban City for Tom. Well: ok, it's a more technical

quickly advanced Taliban, they most sophisticated social media, but we know from reports on the ground. It is horrific in the areas that have already taken over in Afghanistan, women, No, let's leave the home in some of these areas. Girls going to school, they doing public hangings that confiscating smartphones so tell that to the women who are living in these areas that they ve already taken over and the U S is pulling out. They want to keep some kind of a counter terrorism. Effort region, but that's gonna- be complicated because our in Pakistan there. What's the public, it's a very sensitive issue and they might come to see cause arrangement with the PAL Pakistan military forces by its pretty hard to high droids. So so after twenty years David. Indeed, this always angers people. When you put it this way, why the rush why the rush we ve been in Germany since nineteen forty five, we ve been? then in South Korea, since what fifty two fifty three fifty four,

after the war. Why we catch her breath and say: ok, China, Russia, Pakistan Germany, all of our allies, who didn't want the Taliban to get in there. Why did we say gonna get out. If you guys don't step up, we will be part of an equal. By grand coalition there to keep everything and four thousand troops in what I don't get along was painful Joe, as we had a coalition of support their NATO. Our NATO allies were with us on the ground, were shocked that we were thinking pulling out so quickly and not talking about the word. There were. What do we do? I think Administration come in holy things close the talk, a better game about sharing with allies than they sometimes practice, but I sure, your view up, even I were talking before the show I've seen a traveling

in Syria in Afghanistan that small numbers of Eu S forces can have a significant effect on these conflicts in Syria? They just blew out there next day we had very well. Motivated hours, we don't have that in Afghanistan. Are allies have desert, but the idea that that we need he's right away. I think was Joe Biden. Biden embarrassed scars from two thousand nine debates, but Afghanistan and he came- What do we did it over the objections of US military? I think Defence Secretary Austin probably security, adviser, drink Sullivan, oppose this. But you know we're safe, by not pre strong views on Elizabeth says he's always been this way I mean he's been, he was he wanted. He wanted to split Iraq into three pieces for number and he was very frustrated at the long debate and during the Obama administration about this surge. Afghanistan? This is what he it will, but here

The situation will have the twentieth anniversary of nine eleven September and its severe there is a very good chance that Afghanistan will be a complete mess and all of those veterans right all others- men, women, who died Afghanistan and think what was what was the point, an email. I know number veterans to feel it was. At this point- and you know there was- we never had it with our strategy there, was up and down over the years. It was what we want in big than we pull back the way when they again hold back. We covered up ups and downs- and it was just where exactly the same as its history, repeating itself has happened. This happened earlier SAM Willie, you know, I think most Americans exhausted and been exhausted by the years of war following nine eleven and

would you look at Afghanistan? You look at the twenty four two thousand five hundred and two four thousand troops to look at what was happening in Syria. Two thousand five hundred three thousand three thousand five hundred troops. We actually figured out a way to maintain some sense of security in protecting people across in these sounds without sending a hundred thousand hundred fifty thousand people to fight our allies, have to be matching their heads when you're taught whether you're talking about our are Our allies said we're leaving in Afghanistan. Are you talking about the Kurds thing? He waited like the United States, after getting us engaged, can be part of a peacekeeping some twenty five hundred three thousand troops. What kind of a kind of

superpower is that yeah? That's the argument. People, like general betrayal of maids, keep a small force there to respond as as needed, the bite, administrations that they'll be across the border and they can come back and if they need to to suppress anything that happens but make. If you go back and re Dexter, Hence the great war reporters but forever wharf. Twelve years ago, two thousand nine saw that's it was all coming and in this one of the threads of the book is that the Taliban and the people of Afghanistan have something we don't have, which is time and patience they're, not going anywhere and so never. We left whether it was ten years ago or ten years from now there was maybe some return pre nine, eleven afghanistan- you know speaking with a couple of people over the weekend who had a lot to do with the Afghanistan policy and still do something to do with the Afghanistan policy. A couple of from points were raised. One is you are correct. Afghan Stan lives on a different clock and calendar than we do and the other

aspect is we ve been there for twenty years, Twenty years later, as David pointed out just a couple of minutes ago, we basically have a cunt of various armed tribes in Afghanistan. So in terms of keeping a small protective force, their you'd have to worry about. One of the core principles of the american military you'd have to worry. But your own forest protection. You get its twenty five hundred people are going to leave and Afghanistan. Twenty five hundred Americans armed the vastly outnumber and David I'd like to ask you about the point. President Biden raised in Geneva during his press conference after the meeting with Putin when he said the Russians seemed willing to help as much as they could on, Afghanistan as well as IRAN. What do you think he meant by that? Some might there's been something called the extended troika, the witches, a group that include

Russia, the United States, Pakistan, that's been talking trying to get a stable internet all the coalition to prevent a radical take off of Afghanistan collapse. The government- it's been me It's more than this on board meets in Doha, gutter regularly and the press, this doesn't go anywhere its everybody's second most important thing and I think saying that present Biden could do on fire. when he gets a visit from gaudy is to make this much more about. I already- and this is on him- is as much as America sick of this war and in every one of us would would share that. We're not gonna like watching what it looks like as we retreat and the suffering of the afghan afghan people

So this is by the last chance to do something about that MIKE, and I hope he will draw is not going to go anywhere unless the american President wants to go somewhere and its obvious. The Joe Biden has been I got on Afghanistan since that famous man when he threw the napkin there. Of course, he river that story back and like in two thousand and nine or ten thousand turn we went once so I it is. This is extraordinarily difficult in his extraordinary we frustrating our flying Pensacola sitting for a special OB sky was in two thousand. For it's when a rocket blown up and every at that point we said well, if we just sent those troops, Afghanistan, instead of Iraq would be fine, so I said to him, and he was he was in around you know, I've been to a few real Rodya Sousa pre have Geiss et Cetera, weeds and a hundred thousand

troops stories, and what for us all, we shall send a bill rock that's about the stupidest stamp thing. I've ever seen in my life he gets give a hundred thousand troops in Afghanistan and then in Pakistan, but we can't just exactly. Cat. He said it's gonna, be tough and it's gonna be frustrating, but yeah be tough and it's gonna be frustrating, but this is what I heard from Obama. You know ten thousand people die in the serious civil war. Well, it's difficult twenty thousand! Well, it's tough! Fifty three well, there's nothing. We can do about it a hundred thousand a year. I just don't know we can do two hundred five hundred thousand people died. Yes, Sometimes it's difficult being. the United States of America, The answer is not to just retreating, say it's too hard for us to figure out, because guess what would we that half a million people die

in Syria, and there was a refugee crisis. That was a worse refugee crisis since the end of world war, two or ISIS fog or ice because to Europe with a deficit. Exactly the point I made this administration, Joe Biden desperately, wants to turn away from at least he wants to focus on China and basically wants to get out, but you keep getting drunk can the oldest story in the world and what happened when about pulled out of Iraq this will ensure. Not american, starting, care about foreign policy. Until I see people getting beheaded, an airline's getting beheaded and tear, to me on the march, and so he had to go back in and what then it's almost a certainty that this summer is going to be just a horror, show in Afghanistan which have we all know, is the most fertile conditions for terrorism and all these groups to reform on govern territory, so turbine when I turn away, but there's a good chance he's gonna be put

you know you Jeanne and I've said this time and again, whenever I've been critical of what the prisoner bombarded in Syria, on the show saying we put an Iraq enough its absolute the crazy you looked at them, Paul's everybody wanted to get the hell out of Iraq. A nightmare. It was a long war. time wrong place. We all wanted to get out but I ve been adopted. I was wrong in a lot of Americans were wrong. It's not that Simple, I mean dad fought in Afghanistan and Iraq. When I was in high school younger unified, remember the frustration and we that as a family, the frustration of him being over there and how long it was over there and what are you over there for right? All of that is a part of it is. I think that this president, he

has continued to feel that from the moment he has that personal exams himself exactly. He knows what that feels, like our frustrating, that war has been for Americans in this country that seem to have played a huge part in this and, like you were saying, he doesn't want to be in the Middle EAST. He wants to focus on Russia. He wants to focus on turn, that is where they want to because all of their energies and this right house and those are the things that are weighing on them and, like you said in everyone, said, assumes it made. The announcement is this is going the old by violent, no matter what is a very difficult conversation, we're gonna move now to the fight against the pandemic and more one hundred and fifty employees of Houston Methodist Hospital have either resigned or have been fired afterwards. To get the covert nineteen vaccine early, this month. Hospital systems suspended a hundred and seventy eight employees for two weeks without pay for not

Complying with regulations that they be vaccinated against the corona virus. In response Britain, seventeen employee is filed a lawsuit over the requirement, but it was later throne by a federal judge, Houston method was one of the nation's first health systems to impose a vaccine mandate, but more have followed suit, including the magician, pretty of hospitals in Washington D C and Marilyn to listen with ninety five percent doctors basin surveys and see have taken I am the vaccine, have some reason. One of of care workers down and is not just in this use two aspects of this happening across Amerika flat places. Then it just there's a lot of reasons why they want. They feel it's my body. You can tell me what to do an emergency authorization vaccine so therefore its shape their worried that it was developed too quickly. a different reasons. Why why there's say they don't want it, but it is

It seems like a basic requirement that, if you're going to work in health care going to be dealing with people about health care provider that you are perhaps want to be vaccinated, but it just shows you how politicized aspect: still still and how people do not have all the facts about. It It was the best thing in a tone of factual Anthony thought. She was going the door this this weekend in Washington, this best weaken, knocking on he's trying to convince people to get the vaccine. We reported that this morning he spend ninety minutes in Attica, Ostia talking to people on their front. Porch and in ninety minutes you convinced he said six to ten people to get vaccinated, but I think you know fifty one dollar gift certificate. You know. Perhaps you can win a jeep raffle many got some people down to get back into, but it's a very, very slow process. The point is there

still an enormous amount of hesitancy about this vaccine, but they shouldn't be in hospitals. Will you we don't want to send our loved ones? We don't want to go hospitals being treated by people who aren't vaccinated I won't even been a grocery store with people who were vaccinated, there is this this resistance, which ok, if there's we're so resistance people have the reasons we live in a free country. Understand that, but I don't know you stand, though our leaders that have pushed back so hard again the ideas of like vaccine passports people suggesting that somehow this is big brother, when all of our children have quote vaccine sport or they don't get distort kindergarten, and they have been able to do that for what fifty years this is, thing now you know

nothing new and there is a fastening split that new point two, which is at the American Medical Association, has ninety six percent of doctors have at least one shot, but there is a survey from Keyser back in March showed only fifty two percent of frontline workers, nurses, people working in the hospitals, healthcare workers, have it in the hesitancy was that it was knew that it was untasted that it didn't have full. The approval- and that was the argument- some of those nurses made in this case that they lost are the lot of them have been? Let go but you're right. It feels like we ve bumped. Against the ceiling here. The White House yesterday announce it's not going to reach the seventy percent vaccination goal that set for the fourth of July couldn't be any easier frankly to get it? They ve done everything they could. The states have done everything they could there given away cars are given away million dollar lotteries, it's all there for the taking, but the fact remains. There is a certain percentage of the american population. That flatly is not going to get vaccinated even as this dealt a variant moves in and has a lot to healthcare. Exe

very concern for the places. Where vaccination rates are so well Why, then I have. I have people saying: well, it's not approved by the FDA. Yet why is it not who, by the FDA yet well. There is a process I was in Geneva a couple weeks ago, interviewing the guy who runs. Bobby, which is the key part of collapse, the effort to dumb facts at the world it's just for four dimmed. It's so calling for them to hear people in the: U S: health, chemicals, rejecting the vaccine. I get vaccine elderly, vulnerable healthcare workers in these developing countries and what we the problem. We are out of the woods yet here I mean if this virus rips through the developing world, we're going to see more and more mutations and these various didn't come back. She told me and if we have a significant vaccinated population. may evade the vaccines that we have already. So it's a real problem. It's a real big problem and depriving

now, I'm not taking you go under that has to be so maddening, all people I can't even get a vaccine- follows countries that were giving vaccine to that was as announced by the way. I was right that they're looking at us, nothing. We are understood wait. I want to stress that we will take a little take yours exactly that. That's why you keep our eyes. Still I had on morning job more on New York Cities mayor all raise our next guess ass. There are national implications to the very well explain what those are plus what's next, for putting rights after yesterday's republican filibuster in the Senate and on infrastructure, the co chairs of the house problem, solvers caucus join us here to discuss whether about partisan planted stands also.

violent crime, on the rise across the country and local leader, or see few options for re gaining control and, as we mentioned new reporting this morning about former president trumps efforts to get Saturday I live to stop blocking him by getting the Justice Department involved. where it and now you're watching warnings will be right back whether as the politics climate change, the effective state, marijuana law. when the challenges of racial injustice did your day a dose of enlightening articles at MSNBC, daily, ridden perspective by people? You know and trust, like police human indoors, the issue of immigration, many hoskin weighing on voters, depression and frank, big Lucy, writing about national security, along with Michael Steel, offering us take on a couple.

Party lists plank commenting on gender issues and others plus a fresh take Ray morning from me. He's brown start your day with MSNBC, Daily MSNBC, dot com, hey everyone, it's true, mainly MSNBC, corresponded and hosted the pie cast into America the war on drugs and the criminalization of marijuana ruined millions of black lives. Now states like New Jersey, Weed, legal and lawmaker say they want to write the wrongs of the past. When this week's episode, I talked to the woman tasked with making the industry more equitable in the state of New Jersey, and I visit my cousin, the activists and J we'd man to find out whether he believes black people can actually benefit from legalization. Now these guys is rich wake eyes. Now they get the so cannabis wet

is the same exact me. There's no difference this zero different stripe, we're prison cells and they get the get pensions, search for into America. Where were you listening now and follow? Get new episodes every Thursday morning? You get your city, while here Washington we're just shouting at our former president dogs at anchor yards from morning till I wanted the Justice Department to stop today, nightlife wouldn't making fun of this normal net for an american praises. This is really unbelievable. IRAN of ESA now, in March of twenty nineteen sparked and angry tweet from the President asking is that Well, election commission should look into the show quote, knocking him, but according to that, we beast the wound to come. During shave took a step further according to two people

failure, but the matter Trump asked advisers and lawyers in earth twenty nineteen about what the better communications. Commission, the court system and most confusingly to some trump lieutenants. The department of justice could do to probe mitigate ass, an l, Jimmy Kimmel and other less Nine comedy mischief makers, my god Having yesterday, the former president called the story, fake news, but added quote, I do believe that the one hundred percent one side and showed should be considered an illegal campaign. Contribution from the Democratic Party you're, not really what I liner nice about. His denials

Is there always found denial position? See I guess I didn't. I ever did that. However, you can find candlestick. Kids, Mr Grech, remember ever present Trump treated a lot of that in real time when he was watching by the way a re run of the backside. You tweet, hey. Certainly everything today, looking into these late night shows there so mean to me Joe. It's a stark contrast from former President George W Bush, who would throw his back head back and laugh uproariously. It will farewells impersonation of them didn't seek to prosecute in any way there, but my going what a way for a president to occupy his time. Let's turn back to the New York City, mayor, mayoral, primaries, where former police Captain Eric Adams is leading the way in the democratic race, but with New York City using a ranked choice. Voting system for the first time will his lie. hold up Junius, now cosy, YO and founder of the data and analytics company apple cart. Sucks

SAM into such a great god, be with us this morning and we need you. to walk through what exactly happened last night and what happens for mere. First of all, you were just telling us turn out exceeded exe taken some people were worried that not many people go shop at the polls yesterday, but a big number that's correct, it looks turn going to be several hundred thousand votes higher than it? It wasn't. Twenty thirteen, which was the last open seat may oral raised were built. The plaza was chosen, the democratic primary actually going to be the highest turn out since nineteen. Eighty nine, when David Jenkins beat Ed catch in the democratic primary So you ve got Adams at thirty, two percent wily at twenty two, so ten percent spread their captain. Garcia by my wily at about twenty percent. What happens here. Is there another vote out there once you start reshuffling the deck through this? choice system to get either my a wily or Catherine Garcia up ahead of Eric atoms. So the first thing that happened- and as we have to get absentee ballots back it so

Eighty thousand have already been returned, but two hundred twenty thousand or requested and their another several days before their do so. There do in their count in terms of free choice, votes. They won't be able to begin the tabulation first. Second, choice and third choice and fourth choice votes, but that's what will happen next? So, let's put it This is the remedial class. How does this work now in rank choice? Voting? We ve got these this top three. What's the next, appear. How did they reshuffle these votes sharp? So the way it works is if no candidate gets about fifty percent, which is obviously the case here. They will take them did it who received the fewest first choice, votes and they will eliminate them, and then they will reallocate that candidates votes to whoever those voters chose. Second, they will written in repeating do this over and over and over again, until either one candidate gets above fifty. plus one

there are only two candidates laughed and obviously one will have more than the other sea Joe there's nothing to it now so, based based on the Trans, based on but we know so far. Is there anyway to project out where the second rank voting is going to go? Does it look like mostly I mean I saw that Adams Wine, Ribeiro except Manhattan, which really really has to be good for them in the long run, but is there any reason to believe that we're gonna be surprised by the turn out once a second leg funding comes in, so it is possible that second and third choice could swim. Place is eminently possible that it may end up being Garcia Adams, as the final to its approach are widely and items, which is what it looks like right now, but

seems highly unlikely at this point that atoms lead is going to get drunk enough, that there are not foods outstanding and ultimately flip it to one of the other candidates. But it's not impossible so Sasha! When is the next time the New Europe is, will vote so There will be a general election in November, however, general election will be between a Democrat and a Republican in the city that is six hundred and twenty one Democrat to Republican. So it's pretty unlikely to go for anyone except the Democrat. Republican, he does where a variety of things. So I'm sorry for you, my ignorance, but I'd love showing it on the air. So so after they do the rank voting they'd. Do we have one verses to to get to fifty percent, or is it just whoever wins,

in this second round? But let's actually really good question Joe to awaken my question soon, agreements Eiffel it's a very fair question- actually need, so you can rank up to five people on your ballot, but you don't have to rank and so there will be some number of voters whose ballots effectively are thrown out once, however, many candidates they rank are are finished if if they dont rank one of the final two, so against down to the final two candidates, it's really just who has the highest number of votes. It doesn't have to be fifty percent want. Such a report is catching up to this system. What are the advantages of this rank choices, and why was I was a referendum? I am obviously motors of New York decided they wanted it. What is the advantage of this for people who, like it better, also good question so the proponents of this system, people think that this creates were consensus in politics and end in a lot of ways. It actually didn't that was borne out by this campaign. So one of the

suggestions that ran choice voting will limit negative campaigning because when you want to get another candidate. Second choice votes. You obviously much less of an incentive to be seen as someone who is constantly throwing left hooks and right hooks on a debate stage review your television ads something. We saw on the campaign very few of the candidates, actually spend any money at all in terms of financial resources on negative communications. Andrew Yang, actually, I believe, was the only candidate to go negative against another candidate and dear. He you went from leading the poles for most of the race to ultimately me Meeting last night is a matter of fact, Joe and regaining Catherine, Garcia, forms kind of an eleventh hour alliance, asking voters to vote for them in some order, one or two noon and never work so anyway. This is interesting. Sasha, let's go

national implications because we have obviously been looking at the Republican Party for good reason because of a chunk of them are trying delight, destroy. the constitutional republic, just just so we good reason. I'm gonna give us a bright for focusing on like an element of the hot working party, I think, really, though, do long term obligations of twenty twenty and your x rays, lifestyle is going to be with us for a while, and that is because we have a democratic party, That is much more moderate too. We even say Slash conservative most of us. Thank you. Look. It Biden fact that if you read whether you like it social media, you would have thought Biden was going to finish twelve than the democratic primary interest, of Carolina black women said now, wait just how long you I think more go ahead, you guys sectors lattes and we're to get involved in the process. Now you look at me

our city, this same thing, you have people Channing Saward slogans. I think it's a while I what David sure said there are white paper ass of some that are far more progressive somebody strain on issues and even hispanic voters and black voters. I think that bore it out in New York City last night boards, out in the democratic primary. I think their national implications of this could be wrong that what you think, I think, absolutely right. I think you, if atoms or Garcia wins, will be off of the coalition. That looks a lot like the Biden coalition. A coalition of pragmatic folks, voters of color and of right. you're different communities, sort of stick together behind a competent candidate running on experience. I also

you do. You see some of the implications already in the top line, results that are available based off of last night. It look at the Bronx Look at Queens Eric atoms dominated in the outer boroughs, including for ample and Alexandria, Curzio Courteousness congressional districts, now congressional races or not choice, voting there, the congressional race last night, which are obviously wasn't you in that the former republic in police officer who plans to carry his service revolver to the marriage. Mansion would have been the leading candidate in the democratic, primarily now, while that's that's the news. I thank you so much social. We greatly appreciated and think about it here you know you Jeanne, I remember during the middle of last summer, when on. The police debate really was exploding very interesting that that leaders that represented

blogs leaders that represented parts of Brooklyn Pissing wait a SEC inner. What if, slope, wants to defend the place they can be found. The police we want more hops in our schools. We want more cops on our streets, we want and it just again it. sort of went to. I kept hearing from Reverend our leading up to the south, a line of primary. What are you going by some trouble- he goes a long way. Just and he was right. I mean this party is for more moderate, but I need the press give them credit for banks, and I think that's right, and you know you talkin about people in the Eu Representatives in New York who said no to defending the police which Torres right when he even before He was an congressmen using city council. He voted again the funding, the invite people

he became. I talked about that earlier this year, and he said you know the people that live in New York City dont want that. Keep that I represent. Don't want that, and so there is you'd conversation still going on in the Democratic Party on what defining the police actually means. First of all, does not definition. Rights was kind of all over the place about mixed hard for them to make it vision on these things, but you're right, blackboards adjust more pragmatic and they always have been. We saw that you said South Carolina. I also was turning my parents, both from something of which I was talking to folks in and out of my family members, Nowhere voting for bad. You know that gave everybody with. I know it's like he's in, so I kept my colleagues but thats what was going to happen and if it was a little bit surprised, but no black people more because that was well, then it is us at that time. The sinister. What personally to faint president trap tat? Any response is the one candidate within the same Democrats from tunnel

bag man, it was so pragmatism, didn't have a last time that we see a time and again begin from blood Voters who I am members of Congress, it and said we know what we really cannot afford to take a chance. Our voters can afford to take a chance on some wild new plan, we just need to make sure that things get better. in this case, Donald Trump could speak and the politics of this crime issue. I really nasty, I mean by it You can tell because Barton really just more talk about a whole lot, except for the economy and cove at the fact that they doing an event on crime. when they feel the need to actually put out. We know What we're gonna do about crime when you the homicide right around the country spike in certain areas as it is an easy issue for Republicans to demagogues and

this issue of defined, even though most elected officials actually distance themselves from it. When you listen to David Shore, another analyse it did seem to have a way awaiting effect now on democratically down ballot. So when you talk to House Democrats in some of these, in districts they really worried about, will not do so yeah! You know the thing is they don't have to even republicans don't have even demagogue. This people live crying, I mean they live it and David. It looks like this is back to the future election because I suspect a year from now gonna be a lot like nineteen. Seventy five we're gonna, be tough crime and we get talking about inflation, those two themes or are likely to more back- I think by this big to try to get ahead of them. I had a fast. the conversation last week I want to buy this closest advisers is remembering the campaign and twenty twenty when they travel before country. Any some who

The country was very different from what we had expected that message the country was listening to was our message. People wanted to. So it was true after let's more obviously than before, but but It is no accident that the Joe Biden ended up winning the nomination and winning the presidency, because people in the end wanted that central line they learn that are struggling now. To figure out how to make that work here in Washington, which is so polarized which pushes you toward the toward the wings, but in the end, but democratic has John said, have a democratic that talking about crime, twenty one that's pretty interesting. What what? What democratic president has not been a centrist, Time began, and I ask you there has never been you know, I write a liberal Democrat elected president because you ever going back to Carter. I mean right now are very clear,

Obama all things when you talked about borders. What they say is when things get bad for Miracle gets worse for black people, Ryan Brown people right one of the things as when white people get a coal black people get the slow rate. So when you think, when their thinking about what happened and how they think about the voice of the trap and ministration, there's things what we ready to take a chance were not ready to do in a shake things up into a new, because it will it could backfire worse on black people, so that is where that pragmatism come from comes from its hard fought. The ticket very seriously, because that is also hard fought, and so that is one of the things when you progressives in a while on twitter. Spinning come on twitter is a progressive, seem on the Democratic party. That is not really the case right. It is. It is a lot less some clear cut them that their takeover of the devil

party is a lot harder, because the progressive left is alive, it more whiter than the base of the of the democratic process and makes it harder for them to kind of like take over our interest to follow up on what you think. As I know, the Republicans wait Obama. He was someone you go back and look at Brok, Obama's position, personnel, usable the gay marriage. He was why he was opposed to gay marriage? So well as a Christian, I Marriage should just be between a man and a lamb is not really radical. The point that you you look kid position on immigration and other that matters too conservative within Hence. I will say it for the eight thousand time on this show wrong illegal border crossings in the southern border. Fifty year LE he take more people than previous than the previous.

George Bush than almost any other president and again, unless twenty you'd think Gardner in someone's with socialist communist those knocking speed, you bring up a great point. You don't we from the laughed the democratic Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton, Morocco, and for anybody that believes that Barack Obama was left is just talk to democratic activists. There still angry right that he didn't, even if you look at what he says even now what he said about Michael debate as contempt for a sort of the wilderness and and people away, everyone Mandela's pages await us. Are you saying that certain people can't talk about an issue because their white and their men well,

that's just not the country we live in a time and again he is site just every centrist felt the scale back voting rights but which were nowhere. But here port it as I do? We need to get it? It's the word. You keep Goin back to pragmatic. It is this, like a left wing radical work at his position he always a pragmatic in a way was really frustrating to progress and to ask just ahead state for now. Ok, it's gonna break out the big more for more New York City mayors, race also coming up crime was the top. for New York, city voters and it's an issue for cities across the country were going to ask a top White House adviser what to expect from the president when he addresses the surge in violence later today you're watching morning. Job will be right back

whether the politics of climate change, the effect this statement, laws are the challenges of racial injustice, get your dad we dose of enlightening articles at MSNBC, Daily Britain perspective by people. You know and trust like police human indoors the issue of immigration, many hoskin weighing on voters, depression and frank, big Lucy, writing about national security, along with Michael Steel, offering us take on the report, party lists plank commenting on gender issues and others plus a fresh. Take every morning from me he's brown start your Dave within this NBC Daily MSNBC, dot com,

the latter is not exactly as it might so. We're just debating presidency. Rightly fifty three pass the hour. A new report finds that for men who took part in the killing of should impose journalist, Schumacher, show Jeep were trained in the United States According to the New York Times, the saudi men were trained in Arkansas and are a contract approved by the state. and just a year before the twenty eighteen killing the training was conducted by security company tier one group. At times. as there is no other the officials who have proved that training knew the men were involved in a crackdown on this enters in their home country or lose read some cool, this is an example of what happens with this. Is that about partly by the perils of military

partnerships. U S military partnerships with authoritative Parian trees and just whipped. We do training for a lot of countries, this one obviously was a was a big problem and it it's a politically dessert First, I think to end, but it just shows again the because of this. It shows what, after the training, what happens that includes you? Don't you can't control what happens when they go home and adjusts it sort of underscores the problems we have with again. Alliances with countries like set this out. Its David. This has been a long running problem with the United States after the Shove IRAN fell. We all read those stories for years about held CIA up the Shaw in his friend with massive forces from around the World Latin America asian countries. In the Middle EAST.

stores example of how the truth comes up. When I wrote to two years ago, in two thousand and thirteen, the basics of the story In this area version. The point is that tweeting for the extra now started. We stay on. We, the news media, stay on things that matter, so there is significant detail: the dry on this point that we have to be careful about training that your colleagues at times found that advance it further its somebody in another most is gonna. Get is giving up more and I think that's one of the best things about the news media. We don't leave things alone when there's something This is important for our colleague murdered. Brutally former regime that turned out to be trained in part by I'd states, our seeking whether so we're we're we're we're. We're is envy ass with the

I'd administration, aware. Is Saudi Arabia with the United States raised arms length that comes to mind the United States, by much It was decided that probably rightly that Saudi Arabia matters to us that that's important for where security were important for their security and be is just a terrible problem for this administration, the other to maintain relations with a country while making clear that they have severe reservations about him as leader is. but he may be king of Saudi Arabia for many many years to come. So you have to think carefully about how we deal with that How do we make clear? How did the sun is get beyond the scope so that the obvious, This too, is to continue the reforms and is doing in the social sphere in criminal justice to stop arresting people arbitrarily stop imprisoning act.

stop the secret police activities. Things needs to do are obvious the communicated, thereby Americans he just needs to start doing them.