December 8, 2001. Durham, North Carolina. Michael and Kathleen Peterson seemed to have it all. A beautiful home and great careers. She was an executive at Nortel and he was an author. But one night, Kathleen went into the home they shared while Michael continued to lounge outside. After a bit he went in only to discover his wife covered in blood at the bottom of their back staircase. He called 911 to report an accident. After a few hours, Michael Peterson contacted his attorney. Inside the home, prosecutors said that Kathleen Atwater Peterson was attacked and killed by her husband. In this first episode we discuss the night in question and some of the evidence. With the re-release of the documentary The Staircase on Netflix, we have seen our inbox flooded with requests to discuss the documentary and the case. Part two we'll be focused on going through more of the evidence and giving our opinions on what occurred on that fateful night in 2001 at the Peterson home.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
This is an unofficial transcript meant for reference. Accuracy is not guaranteed.
I don't care, I do
great just in we're back
as we are with gotten ahead honour recordings, and they
we forgot to tell everybody that we had a week off so about tat. We re we had a week off now we're back yet just
future reference. We do at least forty four episodes a year, sometimes more yet.
I don't get a lot of time to sit down and read a book moyes on the go.
But I love reading, so the solution is audible, audible,
offers an incredible selection of audio books across every genre, best sellers new releases celebrity memoirs, mysteries, thrillers catch crime, and there too, as an audible member, you can choose one title a month,
leading the latest best sellers and new releases. One of my favorites is
connections, uncovering the real causes of depression and unexpected solutions only
bon audible, let audible help. You discover new ways to laugh and be inspired or be entertained. New members contrived for free for thirty days does audible dot com, slash gaeta, BP or text gdp to five hundred five hundred, that's audible, dot, com, slash gdp or text gaeta BP, two five hundred five hundred to try audible free for thirty days, audible,
calm, slash gaeta BP, Dagmar get word from our
answer. You know when you're watching a crime show and your like wait. Did they
actually do it. Oh they definitely did way. Well almost definitely, or are you just meant to think they did nope, they totally
unless they didn't. If this is you talking to yourself or whoever's, next to you on the couch, we say, keep talking, who are we to judge ready to stream some crime stories? Hulu, it's a crime not to watch while tonight we're gonna
talk about a huge case that is hot,
and the media right now. What
it's a release of her release of a documentary on netflix. This was
actually are second
episode. We ever recorded right
Well right, we did on our second episode cover this case, although it should be,
that's a nice were actually record
a brand new episode
with even more information, so this technically, though, is
sort of one of the inception episodes of the generation. Why and
our committee, the staircase
is what you said you wanted to talk about as your first topic ever on the generation. Why, without this documentary there wouldn't be in egypt
nationwide right. This is one case that will never forget about. It will always be a topic of discussion.
as whatever you think about Michael Peterson and how his wife,
lean died,
there, are so many things that you are here. So we are again,
talking about it and hopefully,
enjoy discussion and learn something from it and I think we might.
A different opinion than when we did this six
almost seven years ago, but I actually didn't go back and we listen our original episode. So I just wanted to go fresh all new perspective,
Where do we start with this one moment?
by talking about the people that
the centre of this case and they would be
Michael Peter sin and his wife, kathleen atwater petersen kathleen was born
in a fifty three in.
carolina, but she grew up
pennsylvania. She was very
logic, aided she was too
in college level, latin classes in high school. She mooted durham thereafter
line to attend duke university, some
said that she was the first female student accepted into that schools engineering programme.
She would earn her bachelor of science degree and my
stars and mechanical engineering kathleen
married fred atwater, and they had one child caitlin, but they later divorced
Michael Petersen was born
tennessee
the son of australian immigrants, his dad
name eugene Iver petersen, but he has a nickname and it's a big
under from down under his moms
It was Elinor, but
yeah. How do you follow in eugene's footsteps, with a nickname like that? I dont know. Michael Peterson,
graduated from duke he had a bachelor
ray and political science, and he was also the editor of the chronicle, which was a daily student newspaper in the mid sixties. Here
so two classes at the law school at the university of north carolina at chapel hill and upon graduating. He took a civilian job with the: u S, department of defense and he was a
I too researched arguments supporting increase military involvement in vietnam, his first wife.
Name patricia sue. She was an l
entry school teacher on the rhine, main air base in west germany and
had two children together, clayton and todd
Nineteen sixty eight Michael peterson.
Enlisted in the marine corps and he, sir
in vietnam.
And in seventy one receives
an honourable discharge with the rank of captain after
He was injured in a car accident that left him with a
minute: disability, Michael
patricia divorced in nineteen eighty seven, his
boys lived with his ex wife and
Michael move to durham north carolina.
His sons would later move in with their dad Michael
some became an author and wrote books that
much all revolved around the vietnam war. Then he ended
working as a newspaper columnist for the durham
Harold, sun and it was
these columns that I guess put him in that
os hairs of some powerful people in that city
He wasn't too kind to some of these
state officials, he was very critical of prosecutor.
and what not so sort of an opinion peace. He would write up what he thought about what is going on and while he had a lot of problems with
the police in that town, as well as the district attorney, and who was that
The district attorney's name was James. Harden junior, keep note of that cause he's
come into play later
Ninety. Ninety: to me,
oh peterson's in love again, and he and his son
heart kathleen by
fourteen room home on cedar street
five years later that they get married and
They have a family and its kathleen,
our caitlin and michaels.
two boys justin
talking about this case, because at some point as ten,
the happened in cases that we discuss something terrible happens.
This is december, eighth, two thousand and one this
The whole point of this podcast is to deconstruct an event. That's
semi questionable. We have a
questionable night with
Michael Petersen and his wife kathleen where they are our poor.
side. Having wine kathleen decide
she's gonna call it a night or she has a phone.
how to make its about fifty
five degrees outside and its nighttime? It's not like it,
snow on the ground or anything. That's a little cool out and according to
Michael computer, he hangs outside for at least forty five minutes
the kathleen peters ngos inside right kathleen
has a call with coworker around eleven o clock.
she's waiting for an email, it's something to do
with her business,
she is going on in the morning thanks
I'd, be at work at ten, a m yeah, and so
because there's.
An email and whatnot. She runs upstairs to use Michael's computer
which normally she doesn't according to some.
She doesn't uses computer, she doesn't go into his office because it is, but she did it on this-
because it was just easier.
check your email and do this phone call right from there and mike
Peterson said he has a smoke
while she's inside at some point,
He goes inside the house in this is some time around
two thirty in the morning,
and when he goes inside the house,
quiet, and he finds Kathleen Lange
at the foot of the stairs in this
dare case leading up to his office in a pool of blood and is not just a poor blood. It's kind of a gore fast and
He is very shocked by this and calls nine one one.
There's blood all over the wall around her: it's not just a pool blood. It's not just
a little bit spatter on one wall. It is everywhere it's
not really clear exactly when she goes into the house and.
depending on how you take what Michael Petersen says, this could have been
some time between twelve thirty, two
one thirty or
or even between one forty five
in two in the morning, so
Maybe that's because he's chilling out by the pool relaxing drinking having a smoke he's not exact
checking, is watching his his wife
it goes into the house. That's what he knows
so this is kind of a guesstimate. I guess, but we know that the
now comes in close to midnight. We can
least use that as some sort of gauge
for when we know she goes into the house. But his far
coming back out and then coming back again. We d
have a clear picture.
but we know at least before midnight. She goes into the house. The
in that sense it to her. Her name is Helen thee,
email came in, I think around eleven forty five
it was never opened, it was basically
Blank email with an attachment was
you're, a powerpoint attachment and
this email was never read and Helen.
was a coworker appear at nor tell the phone company and we he talked about caffeine, said
cation. She was making close to a hundred and fifty thousand dollars a year at this job. That's like director, vp level, you upper management level at a phone company.
Michael Petersen called nine one, one at tooth
one a m, and he was reporting an accident
and he said his wife was still breathing at that point-
operator asked him what kind of accident and Michael said she
down the stairs she still breathing. Please come
You ve seen the documentary or, if you ve heard this phone call you,
make your own determination on how believable he sounds. I have
I numerous articles that shreck
This nine, when one call part and say how
guilty is
the face of it. When I hear it I hear
and that sounds very concerned. I don't hear any deception, really
his voice- and I dont really
much stock and nine one one calls anymore and how
but he sounds because we have on record
people that have called nine one wanna get every single detail wrong. Yet there innocent
and we have others that are key
calm, sound totally believable and their one
two percent guilty
don't listen to his call and find anything that deceiving myself. What do you think her? I think its useful just
the point of reference he's going to forty one to report that his
I've had a terrible accident for me
this just darts everything right here. So it's a point of reference and
They do an autopsy toxicology test. What have you they can start
compare things with this time. Absolute.
he's basically saying that
she went in and then later
he went in, and this is how he found her
he calls soon after he gets off the line,
to then say that is
it is no longer breathing.
So the situations gotten worse and he's calling
saying hey, you need to get her sooner she's not breathing any longer, and he
It really is sign off that call. He just
of goes away at two forty eight in the morning,
a paramedics show up and they find
kathleen peterson dead at the bottom of the stairs they have,
some observations that they make when they show up
one is there's a lot of blood,
I only go in a. We never talk about the the blood.
details per se, but it means something in this case
And anyone who knows anything about it knows that
They also notice that a lot of the blood appears dry, meaning
it's been there for a while. So doesn't really
dictate a fresh fall or afresh accident its
happened a while ago, Michael
called his son todd.
and he shows up according to talk just after the ambulance and im, tease,
And he sees what's going on here, but it's not intel
three, twenty four, a m that
investigators starts
securing the scene and not allowing movement through the house, so
can imagine a view,
bloody, seen multiple people
went around doing things it can contained crime scene
some of the things that happened were Michael, went over to his wife,
And embraced her,
her into his arms, which
as we know if something
weapons you're, not supposed to touch the person whose whose down, because you could be contaminating the crime scene or it's a crime scene.
injuring them further, unless the nine on one operator said do
pr it's one of those things
where I can understand him embracing his wife is
had a major accident. What was known at the time that she was dead at least
This case she had already passed and his
distraught? Also, Todd went to the kitchen
and apparently tracks and blood in there. He also
moved his dad over to a couch and that tracks
blood over there.
The bloody seem like that
people moving around. Also you had neighbours showing up and coming into the house. This
something like what happened in the germany ramsay case, where, if you don't
down the scene
people moving around and you don't know what they have changed, you dont know if their blood,
footprints are going off to go clean up or if it was something innocent
like they're just moving over to the couch how'd. You interpret these footprints. It's really
blood on a counter. Did it come from todd going in there and getting a drink or
Michael petersen in there, that's really difficult to say now between forfeit
teen at five o clock in the morning: peterson
was given the go ahead by by some
officer to go up to his office
and at five a m
Oh Peter calls his attorney. So unless
than three hours he's
de calling his lawyer and here
his computer doing stuff- doesn't look good right,
while an investigation
reveal some answers
in regard to the computer use so these
medics, these police officers, when they get there, they they heard,
Word accident right from the outset
after when they first get there, maybe
spend a horrible accident, a fall down the stairs.
as these officers are investigating. It starts
look more like murder to them. Bright will ya mean
I can't say that
anyone knows
blood evidence or whatever, but when you just look at the scene with untrained eyes, it looks horrible and it does not look like an axe.
How was Michael pearson dressed when they,
medics and when the officers awry
wearing shorts and a teacher without shoes.
They found his shoes and his socks by his wife, which I guess
If you want to give him a pass on this, you could say well, he had tracked through.
And you didn't want to track blood around the house, so he took his shoes off. I would be one explanation. I guess
there are also white towels mall,
had been white, but they result in blood. There
Neither head to give her support. Also on the spatter on the wall, it appears that there was a swipe baker.
a suave like somebody took one of those towels and wipe the wall.
But then there's more spatter, almost on top of that swipe some kind of weird looking so
he's, wearing t, shirt and shorts.
later on the beer forenoon,
meteorologist, who will determine from a triangulation of weather stations the exact temperature that night, which was fifty?
four degrees, so people question
why was he wearing a t, shirt and shorts and such cold weather hanging out outside if you care taken
to get a word from our new sponsor price line. Do you have a group chat where you continuously talk about summer get, but never
they go anywhere. Well,
summers? Finally, here it's time to get out of the office or your house and get a change of scenery with price line you can save up to sixty percent on your favor hotels plus, find amazing deals on car rentals, an flights, and when you save money you can explore more. That means more beautiful views and experiences and more poolside fun doesn't matter where you travel zones are out of the office. I always use price line to find the lowest rates out there and you should do a price line. Every trip is a big deal,
So when you ready to book your next summer, adventure visit price lined up com for the best deals that are
we get more out of it.
Moment to get a word from our sponsor cove co
believes everyone deserves to feel secure,
purity shouldn't just before the rich and famous that's why they make home security systems
that are easy to install, affordable and reliable cove arrives configured for your home and you install it and just mere minutes. No technician required and it's easy to control from the sleek touch screen or up its professional grade systems price to be affordable and come with life.
Equipment, warranties, faster
spawns times thing competitors because threats, don't sleep sakharov, doesn't either no contracts. Twenty four by setting friendly customer support, try the number one customer rated home security system order today and get fifty percent off your customized system get started
cove, smart dot com. They found
and bloodstains on the front door?
the outside the house on the walkway and blue
on the kitchen sink and a couple drops in the hallway up by the ceiling outside of the staircase
but again this wasn't a locked down crime scene or anything. We have people
rummaging around. Where did these droplets come from? Was it
during the accident or the attack, or was it cry
contamination. After the fact they find
the wine bottle and glasses on the counter these are tested. They come back with.
in four Michael petersen, but they don't find any prince from Kathleen. Although some of the prince are,
much, and this is something that happens. I mean when
grab, something you don't always leave perfect prints, there's no way to
move necessarily it though
smudges were left by kathleen. They fight
a condom that appears to have been used? They had found it
bedroom, they tested, but
you don't find any seamen, but we can-
Talk about all this evidence, but one other thing
they do, is they will analyze the computer to see if there's any
honour. As we know, if you have a sir
history
They will analyze that and of theirs,
Anything suggestive of a b
das or foul play at all.
anything suggesting foul play. They were latch on to that
they do find with this. Computer, though, is that there was
program used on it to delete a lot of photographs around the day or two of catholic staff. Hundreds of photos were deleted. No,
I know that there are programmes that you can schedule to run clean ups, but
Usually those are internet, temp files and what not? This doesn't appear to be that
this is deleting photos out of normal
directories and not
an internet browser history. So it's
little odd that this is happening.
I guess we should say images, but all you need to know is there were alive
of images on this computer that
being deleted from
for the time that she died and, after so could be.
Suspicious
would say it is suspicious. I, if my wife had a terrible accident,
The images on my computer, my internet history, is actually the last thing I'm gonna. Think of that's not
something I would
concerned with at that point, it would be my wife, it's about two months
Kathleen died that the
medical examiner released, her
autopsy report, one
the things that really stood out about. It was the back of care
they skull there. These
deep, lacerations, seven of them on her scalp across the back over her head, and you look at that and you
I think how does it happen from a fall down? The stairs
really add up
fall down. The stairs is what Michael Petersen thought it happened.
He didn't say: that's what happened he so this we, he thought must have happened, but these are
huge, deep gashes, where
literally her skull is exposed
and now I know that is somebody falls
stairs day can gash there had horribly. Also they can crack their skull. Open does
a lot of terrible things that can happen with a fall down the stairs, but
the amount. The number of lacerations here is very questionable, because all of the blood is
the bottom of the staircase it doesn't start at the top or in the middle or anything it's all at the bottom. So we're thinking
How do you hate your head that many times and cause this much damage in such a shortfall? This
examiner states that Kathleen Petersen must have been bludgeoned death cause of death,
It sounds like blunt forest trauma or
possibly bleeding to death from the wounds.
She also says that the neurons in our brain heart
flamed or shrivelled, which
means there is a lack of oxygen to them, and she says that
only happens after two to eight hours of oxygen depletion, so two hours and we go back
to Michael sang. Forty five
minutes later I went in the house that time
ram, at least in the shortest one. Isn't adding up
and in the longest one six to eight hours, definitely isn't adding up yeah. It's throwing light
doubt on his story in terms of the timeline
because of this report, Michael Petersen, is
rested for the murder of his wife and charged with first degree murder. Now, here's where it gets interesting, because my
petersen has already talked to his lawyer carry sudden and
start building a defence for him and fight
a high and lawyer named David rudolf who,
has a reputation and where's flashy suits notices, durham north carolina early, two thousands
appears like it's late eighties. Early nineties, though, if you watch documentary, I was kind of gear.
Link at some of the fashions I saw so when
His lawyer, rude off, shows up. He looks out of place
lawyer from new york and a thousand dollar suit. He just he sticks
I'm just saying that it, it just looks or appears that
Michael Petersen, is this rich guy
who can hire rich lawyer and
nobody really likes an elite guy like that. I think
just watching the documentary and seeing the reaction of people to his
go team showing up is a little telling
during the pre trial,
legal malay that happens between pay,
secure and defence. They
are doing discovery there. Finding evidence there finding
bunch of emails that
oh Petersen had printed out
corresponding with a male,
escort day
are arguing these points. There arguing points about the blood evidence
and lo and behold, fancy grace gets hold of some of this and is,
with it on national news getting some of the points
extremely wrong
thinking to myself. How is this leaking to the press?
trial, hasn't even officially started yet and Nancy has the information? Just doesn't
good, you say, doesn't look good, doesn't look good for who, I think the prosecution
in the state, because I will,
I believe that the defence would leak this type.
information out because it was
more prejudicial towards Michael peterson
but you're saying that, like you, expect someone hold them accountable if they did do such a thing, I think
but maybe we should be talking about is how it looks for Michael Petersen, where this
I'll leaking out, and now people are judging him in a big part of
This is his by
sexual lifestyle
homosexual lifestyle, as they keep painting it- and this is because
the trial even starts. This is coming out. I think the state, the prosecutor
leak this information and will find out why later when they make other statements, but we don't have proof of that
no, no! This is an allegation on my part completely. It's a guess, yeah how
is this information leak to the press? You know you got to follow who's going to benefit from this, probably not the judge. No, definitely not the judge, the prosecutor,
that will be up against Michael Petersen in his legal team in court.
is none other than james.
art and junior, which is the same,
m attorney that
computers and was very critical of in his columns, no conflict of interest there yet and so
I mean for me this seemed really odd, because you have this uncut
terrible situation between a nuisance
bert journalist and then
tourney
Now, they're going to be in court together facing off it just seems really odd.
There wasn't another attorney around, they could have prosecuted, but I get it's a hype,
the case and hardened
the guy that takes these, so I
a little bit of a problem with it. I think that a chain
Then you might have been an order because of the information that was already leaked and the high profile case, the
d, a being who he is I'm thinkin
make a change of then you might have been an order, but that didn't happen. Let's
about some of the stuff to happens at trial. The
Prosecution has to come up with a mole
The theory of our thing has
and why it happened. What do they believe happened in this case?
why Kathleen died, while others too motives that they throw out there one is that there in debt kathleen her.
had a million
Dollar life insurance policy. So
Michael, had motive to murder her to get this pay out to pay off all these debts because they were slowly going more.
More underwater. The second motive is kathleen, goes up to his computer.
To email, coworker, and she finds the gay images that he has.
On his computer. The emails that yet
printed out in the drawer soliciting and she finds
this infidelity and she
in france, him about it.
Computers and doesn't like this, and he takes a blow poke fire poker and he beats her over the head with it at the bottom of this.
there's the reason why they pick out a blow poke is because another fan
remember had gifted everyone.
family matching blow pokes and they couldn't find that blow poke
the night of the murder or subsequent sir?
Is it the house so
assumed hey. That is a lightweight metal instrument that could be used
to hit someone strike. Someone over the head, with causing
age your tears and rips in the flesh, but not quite heavy enough to cause school fractures on catholics.
And of course, if it's not at the house, that means he disposed of it exactly so they go with
this is the murder weapon in that
Bludgeoned her beat her at the base of the stairs
get into the financials real, quick kathleen.
is the one making the money
appears in apparently hadn't made any money for the last several years. Now,
the free loader and the relationship, and
he was also spending a lot of money. They were but a high
in forty two thousand dollars in debt on their credit cards, and when we talked about this before the podcast, you said what the heck was
bending all that money on. He did have subscriptions to lots of different stuff, whether it be why
Subscriptions magazine subscriptions or website subscriptions right,
and so she was making close to home-
fifty thousand dollars a year. They were living in a home that was valued at more than a million dollars
The home was in her name now is
and they had a lot of
in our view, wanna say assets. If you total up,
everything they have. What
two million dollars worth of actual worth right but-
the problem is theirs.
forty, two thousand hours and debt? That's credit card debt by the way, this
it isn't just you know: oh they have a home loan or a right car loan. This is straight up credit card debt and then her job
nor tell while it
and going away necessarily was being threatened because they were doing lay offs here and there the company was exe.
And seeing a downturn and
She was worried about that. I worked its
and for many many years and every single year with every single re and merger. Now the round, alas- and you always had
in the back of your mind, that you're gonna lose your job. Specially upper management because
is there a sort of replaceable
managers can be a manager anywhere, you know so there's
the departments in companies and especially ever management that you're kind of a diamond dozen
I could see how this could be a real fear for her and Michael he was
we've been emailing his ex wife asking her to
do you like a mortgage on her house? So she could pull like thirty
thousand dollars to help pay off his sons, student loans,
his sons both were carrying a lot of debt, and
it's interesting because there's an email about this to patty-
Ex wife and he's explaining that she could get
Thirty thousand dollars to help out, because
of his sons were basically underwater. Their bill
were higher than the amount they had coming in so end, there
he says he can't talk to kathleen about this.
The things he also says is that one of his sons has a five hundred dollars a month car payment. When you add up
cost of school- the cost still
just feeding yourself, then not making a lot of money.
he's trying to help them out. One
it does show as these concerned by it
he's also expressing that he's hoping that they can get out of the debt and move on all the while,
he has a lot of debt. There is alive
Question about this, because people will say wolf their work, two million dollars. Then why would a hundred forty two thousand dollars in credit card debt? Be a problem because
the lose your house and all your material possessions paid off. That's that's why it's problem and if
he's not making any money and he's the big spend
in this relationship and Kathleen, doesn't like that there is the problem
It has to be a tough letter to write, contacting or ex wife, seeing if show
about your kids,
on the other hand, he's doing what he s too, for his kids. I guess, and I
dont know if the debt
The money? I don't know how much we
I put on that as a motive. I absolutely think it is a motive or can be a motive, but there's somebody p,
well that live in debt. So many people
that live on credit. I can
just say: oh you're in debt, you could have killed somebody. I just I can't make that leap, but it definitely is emotive and if she
possibly going to lose her job, which was a real possibility. Then they can't stand that house.
and he loved that house they're,
lose their lifestyle right so but, on the other hand,
if she were to dine, he can collect on the insurance, then he sat life is good
he's in the short term. He would have the money now, let's go
the second motive, he is bisexual
he was looking for a male companion to her
sexual relations with outside of the marriage according to
I call it was
the I I don't know how a better way to put this but sort of a don't ask, don't tell understanding that he did this the rest of the family does.
This kind of a shocker to them. They had no idea. So, if kathleen didn't know,
about this. This is going to be an argument is going to be a fight. This is going to be a separation. This is
to be a divorce and she did
know about it, then yeah you get to throw the motive out. It's a real question.
because on one hand people said, while she didn't go into his office, she didn't uses computer. So if he had pronounced,
of emails with an escort or
images on his computer? Maybe he didn't
spectra to ever see those things I'm just
is that a printed out as emails and had him in folders
drawer. Like I mean I get it, I get wiping
print out emails because you want a reference it you want to write on it, but the,
this kind of emails really
it is odd and also when he would make
all to this escort he used
home phone here,
it's not like he tried to hide it really. I mean she could look,
their phone bill and figure out
This is an odd number, maybe or amusing
like it says gay esquire,
isn't it right so maybe
He doesn't need to hide it as long as she's not around when he's calling of hiding
in plain sight is definitely an option or she knows about it. But it's hard to tell. I think that,
him getting a cell phone to make these cause that's another bill, so they can't really afford that
so- how else is going to call well
he's hiding it
just assume he would go down the street and use a pay phone or something like that, but I think he's too lazy this,
escort was going to be in town, and so they were supposed to meet up on a certain day.
Never happened because
escort decided ere. I don't feel up to it and
in the actual emails to brad Michael
Petersen actually says: I'm married happily
to my wife- and this is
purely sex, like he'd, makes it
very clear that he's happily married, so it sort of weird
when that comes up and trial, because their reading these emails, which their trying
paint as infidelity
yet in the emails he sang, I'm happily married, so not a bad
marriage cause even telling this guy he's happily married
That's what it says in the email, so it doesn't exactly work for them in court. Well, here's my
First problem I have with the prosecution. Actually, there
all the emails and
considered admissible and on one hundred percent on board with
because they were found during a a search of the home.
The information on the computer
get, is admissible. I think it does show a motive. Possibly they give
to the jury. The jury is allowed to read.
all of those emails print out, there's hundreds of them day,
in brad in two
Try to verify that brad as a real person and that him
Michael had talked corresponded.
And were planning on meeting brad's. I guess they asked brad. What do you
supply to your clients, unease his companionship and then they say is adding
We saxony says yes,
and then they say what kind of sex and brad is sort of caught off guard. Can I say yes, he says,
anal sex there? Really pandering to anyone, that's homophobic? At that point, I think they establish their point with the emails
I think they establish their point bringing brad on the stand.
But to literally get that graphic to me is totally uncalled for
And the only reason to do that is to pay.
you're too somebody that's homophobic or bigoted. Yet the way you get
people aligned against another person is to paint that other person is someone who's different,
now they already sort of done that with all the emails and even bring brad on the stand, but now there s
for information that just seems unnecessary and, like you said
probably will, if there's
on the jury. Who does discriminate. This will just get them against Michael Petersen. I just think
that you have enough evidence you're proving your case with
go evidence are proving it with
circumstantial evidence you don't
after use prejudice to go after somebody and that's when at least the state lost me in their tactics that they use doing
this case I mean just one of the things that work for them is they pointed out there
years earlier way.
Oh Petersen ran for mayor. He had
some claims that turned out to be not true. He said
he had gotten a silver star, a bronze star, valor and to purple hearts, and he said,
documentation to prove this by it
his stories about how he was wounded
vietnam, in
and all this. It turns out that this wasn't true
yet he hadn't one all those metals, he hadn't been wounded,
shrapnel are in combat. None of that was true. He was essentially
You know, exaggerating his military career to sound like a bad ass
We don't mention that he had had an accident and that's actually how you'd gotten injured it had nothing to do with getting shrapnel, but this could be achieved
on because shows you the liar.
If he's willing to lie about that, but will they
that against him in his trial. That's a whole different thing, but let's go back to the
the crime sorry
a graphic that we're gonna be talking about blood here and they buy
in a blood analysis
spatter analysis. Guy named dwayne deeper, he will do
pray much reenactments. He will hit a bloody sponge with
the blow poke essentially and create spatter that
looks very much like what they find at the bottom of the stairs. He re creates a whole,
scenario of how she was beaten,
how the spatter was directed at the walls
how spouter ended up on the inside
of his shorts that night
dwayne will show that you can cause
spatter along this wall and then
hell even say that there's cast off into the hallway. That's really high up bright eyed. How do you get a blood droplet up by the ceiling? Will that's a cast off is
leading to dwayne alot of dwiggins research and
testimony will come.
Your fire later, but its very
compelling at the time of the trial, to see him
black blood, oliver wall and oliver himself
in a very similar fashion of what you see at the crime scene.
Small business owners protect what you ve built with more than thirty cos
Michael insurance coverage options, including commercial, otto, general liability and business owners, policies plus get personalized disco
for business experience prior insurance and more get it
in his little as six minutes at progressive commercial dot, com, progressive,
casualty. Insurance company and affiliates discounts uncovered selections not available in all states are situations.
the defence has their own export, its doktor henry lee alot of people that
watch or listen to true crime shows have hurt
the sky and
again I have to make this
provision because
before the trial, the defence
actually had a, I guess- sample, jury or test jury that they present
their case to and when
Dr Lee was talking about the blood evidence summit
test juror said you know a economy
the ex broken english and he knows a lot.
big words, and I can't stop listening to him in that slake wow,
doktor. Lee is very proficient in his field and now,
what he's talking about, but again ganum
I'm wondering why are people not into the sky? Is it because of the way he speak?
is it because of his race. I dont know, but it doesn't
I'm off well hand, he could have worked against Michael Peterson
according to doktor Lee he says there
too much blood. Because of
location where most of the blood is. He thinks it's not so clear.
That it was an attack because he would have expected it to look different, but
according to him. He believes that this,
Spatter is from Kathleen exe
selling blood out of her mouth and at trial? He actually
puts catch up into his mouth and then
blows out, spit it out all over the wall. What would be the wall yeah? He does
counter a lot of what dwayne says like the droplet
in the hallway he says: that's not cast off, because a cast off
is a series of droplets. Not one is: are you can't
Hey something's a cast off pattern. You know like you're, hitting someone with the metal bar
you swing back up for the next round, cas off a line of blood,
he says you can't determine that from one droplet tactic,
the kind of tears dwiggins whole analysis up during trial, and there are more
to buy books and analysis that go against what dwayne says, but
dwayne has is videos in his tasks and his experiments and he's very
very persuasive, doing
and had submitted. All
his task and experiments to the prosecution,
and then, when it presented and trial Michael peter
defence team says what what
that again
about this is Duane's. Test results
and the defences like. Can we get
Copy of that
so a problem here where
the blood analysis, which is literally the main point of why
Michael Petersen is being tried, hasn't been supply,
to the defence and it's just
egg whoops e, sorry about that, and it's not even
addressed at all by the judge or anybody, but the defence.
came feels like they ve been blindsided now and then
To literally look at this evidence, give it to Lee all at the last minute.
Really, in essence, what the debate is is the prosecution is saying they Kathleen was beaten to death.
And the defence is saying it was an accident. She fell down. The stairs
but they're, not even saying she fell all the way down the stairs there say
that she was coming in. There was going up and then fell backwards,
possibly because she was drinking yeah. She had alcohol in her blood system and she was wearing football
Now what
alcohol level did she have
is below what would be considered over the legal limit yeah, I think so
point: zero. Seven. She was
we're whiners, yeah yeah, so
had? Obviously, some alcohol one or two glasses of wine?
by their saying because she was wearing foot flops and she
done some drinking and it was late that she fell backwards and then
that's how it all started
Do a recreation where she falls back
hits her head on the. I guess. The dog
or frame leading into the staircase and then falls down
hits her head again proceed,
to try to stand up and slips and falls again
thus creating multiple lacerations on her head. I'm look.
Yet the recreation and just
shaking my head like I mean
The walls and and stares made out of razor
aids and knives lake. I don't see this happen.
Now again. I know you can mess yourself up, but the bad fall down the stairs
The amount is just really
to get over here
things are struck, me was. If she was drinking, then pie
simply her bloodstained out and surely more now, that's true and its thinned out my drive faster too.
the prosecution of course- and I I'll say this- I think that their whole recreation
how they say she fell his terrible. It's it's almost laughable. I would.
I would agree, I dont understand how, anyway sees that actually thinks it's possible lee seem to be very careful with his wording when talking about the blood evidence
in framing it as an accident.
I guess I feel like he's is very careful with his wording.
add most of the cross examination of lee talks about how he approved.
Dwayne because he autographed a book,
today in and unlike really, that's it
crediting Lee is he's signed, a book saying egg,
but the good work dwayne you
I have signed my autograph for somebody and then they turn out to be a terrible person. You're going to say: oh we'll just thought they were a good person. He signed his autograph, I just it
a really weak point that they make in
the documentary again, it's the document,
can be a little bias and showing what they want to show by the prestige
Does show why this isn't a simple fall down the stairs, because catholic
had bruising on the tops of her arms and on her face, and she even has damaged cartilage in her neck. There
recreation of her fall. They have her hitting her neck on one of the steps centrally so be
It seems that most who of reviewed this car legendary say it's indicative of
strangulation yeah? That's from the
autopsy results and what not
it's not is clear. It just seems like such a small
all bruising such a minute damage to the college that I'm wishy washy on that. But how do you
get an injury. Their falling down. The stairs
we stood out to me mostly was the bruising now because, if she's
only backward, then why
She had bruising on the tops of her arms and on her face when she's falling backward in their recreation
yeah. The the injury she has are just so random for a fall down the stairs
In most cases, not necessarily this one, but in most cases
when someone has injuries to their arms and their face, it's because their being attacked the d.
Of wounds you're blocking yourself you're, putting her arms up and you're getting hit there? What they don't find out
similar bruises on her lower extremities, meaning you would think if she felt
on the stairs that she would have been paid.
up in the legs or something, but they don't see that the other.
Piece of evidence. That shows that I would say that she was attacked is there.
a bloody shoe print on the back of her pants may,
by michael beer since shoe this,
really isn't addressed by the defence. It's one
the things where is she
found laying on her back slumped on the stairs
there's no reason for a footprint to be on the back of her leg.
even if he did embrace her
just doesn't add up, so you have to
sort of assumed that the body was moved or something more in a we
said how the crime scene wasn't locked down for a while,
they did use luminal in the house. They found bare feet going from
where Kathleen was to the kitchen and to the sink so
Michael Petersen comes in. He find
His wife has had this terrible accident, any
ex off issues in his socks and he walks to the sink in the kitchen? I dont understand:
I don't understand it either, but it happened, but it has rightly
You can't say it might have been taught it might have been this person. I know he.
The only one who had his socks and choose off. I guess
I only explanation is
oh. It was really bloody scene and he didn't want to track blood to the house. Now you can use whatever
logic you want on. Does he disliked
keep a clean house, or was he not trying to
blood everywhere cause it's a murder scene. I dont think he's being
careful in that regard, because he went and embraced. His wife
it's not like he's trying to be careful this?
is more a suggestive of a clean up,
so when you add in the towel
and there are some smears also
people saw him working on the front of his shorts, trying to
spain off, so it's very suspicious and at trial. Here,
between the blood, spatter analysis and the shoe print and
the questions about infidelity or his
your preferences. There was a lot
working against Michael petersen in this trial, but
This is an where it ends no, and in just I want a pause
quick on the clean up aspect of this there was what appeared to be swipe.
on the wall and a step were somebody wiped the blue
and then there was additional spatter
almost as if oh she's dead,
clean up the crime scene. Oh she's
dead, additional spatter. It doesn't look good, yet the defence team,
we'll show pictures that law enforcement took up the scene anymore,
pitcher. You have large droplets of blood
the wall
and then another picture it looks like they ve been wiped away
and the defence teams, like the scene, was locked down the only people,
that were involved here now our law enforcement.
So why does this look different way?
these two droplets, a blood appear to have been wiped were
passed over something you know, pure less, then and
I don't have an explanation for this, but it's obvious that law enforcement was involved at that point.
and so did they inadvertently
Cause these swipes today have any,
the do with what looks like a clean up of the scene,
This suggestion that may be some was trying to set him up to make em look worse from what I
till they were more or less suggesting that any evidence of clean up, while the
since been tainted by law enforcement. So you can't say that he cleaned anything up
or this was intentional or whatever they didn't go extreme with it. They just work
trying to say: hey, there's what appears to be clean up here, but that doesn't explain a bloody foot. Printers bloody-
print on the back relay that doesn't explain, footsteps to the kitchen. It doesn't exist.
Laying a droplet outside doesn't explain other places where blood is found, so we reach
the end of part one, because we
pretty long with this episode, writer yeah. We we realize,
you want to stay here for two hours straight, so we split
the two upset so you're going to hear
our opinions and what not, on the second one,
don't, leave us, hang it and don't skip the second episode you gotta here too,
the final resolution here party will be out next week. We like to think
love for sponsoring today's episode. Third love
his passionate about the perfect fit and they build.
It's time for your broad to fit. You
the other way around. Their collections are designed by women for women. So you will love the way you feel under each and every look and now
offer over seventy sizes and more than a dozen styles, so you'll find the perfect bra for every moment and every outfit get fifteen percent off your
where's purchase by going to third love dot com, slash Jen! Why? Today
the.
When you're scrolling through social media. How can you tell what's real anything can be posted on line without being fact checked, but if you heard about the secret to permanent weight loss, wouldn't you give it a follow
tommy sucker brought founder of the trendy, high fibre effect or diet hasta la
followers, including megan, kelly and supermodel olivia cocoa, but allegation
of troubling side effect of the diet began to surface and people started a question: is she selling powder or power Emily jealous a popular fashion, influence her saw these allegations and put the diet on blast to her own large social following she launched a crusade to x.
Those tanya any the f factor diet. What was once an online feud escalated into the real world resulting in threats, lawsuits and a whole lot of
Emma from wondering comes a new series about wealth. Wellness and influence listened a fed up on it.
what podcasts amazon, music, spotify or you
less than early an ad free by joining, wondering plus in the wonder YAP.
Transcript generated on 2022-08-27.